Journal of the American Chemical Society
Communication
could not be employed easily on the process scale, as three
steps are needed to install the blocking group (1. N-amination
using hydroxylamine-O-sulfonic acid, 2. tosylation, and 3.
methylation with Meerwein’s salt along with one column
purification and one recrystallization). The Buchwald group
reported a Cu-catalyzed, selective C-4 functionalization of
pyridine with styrenes without a covalent blocking group, via a
novel intramolecular rearrangement mechanism mediated by a
pyridine-coordinated copper species.7e,h Herein we disclose a
highly practical method featuring a new blocking group based
on a simple fumarate backbone (6a) enabling classic Minisci
decarboxylative alkylations to take place with exquisite
selectivity at C-4 (Figure 1C) under acid-free conditions.
Emblematic of this advance is the preparation of 4-cyclo-
hexylpyridine (8). Subjecting pyridine under four different
Minisci-type conditions, the product cannot be accessed in a
synthetically useful yield, and a mixture of isomers was
observed.12
Tactically, scalable access to valuable structures such as 8
(81% isolated yield from 6a) can now be enabled with a
dramatic reduction in cost. From a strategic perspective, this
work opens a new dimension of retrosynthetic logic for use of
the Minisci transform at an early rather than late stage.
Guided by a colleague at Syngenta (E.G.), several criteria
needed to be met for a practical blocking group (BG) design,
such as (1) derivation from feedstock materials (ca. $5/mol),
(2) simple installation and removal, (3) high stability, ease of
handling, and solubility in multiple solvents, and most
critically, (4) complete regiochemical control to avoid the
need for any chromatography. Toward this end, multiple BGs
were explored, with most falling into one of two categories
(Figure 2A): (1) simple BG installation with either modest or
low reactivity under Minisci conditions (BG1, 2, 4, 6) or (2)
difficulty in forming a stable BG adduct. After extensive
exploration, BG10 emerged as an ideal candidate satisfying all
of the criteria laid out above. BG9 was the only other
moderately successful one; however it exhibited reduced
reactivity toward Minisci addition. The preparation of
pyridinium 6a with BG10 could be prepared through a simple,
chromatography-free, two-step sequence starting from com-
modity materials (pyridine and maleic acid) followed by
esterification. The structure of pyridinium 6a was confirmed by
X-ray crystallography and contained the ethyl sulfate as a
counteranion. This crystalline salt represents a straightforward
gateway to a variety of C-4 alkylated pyridines (vide infra) and
has been commercialized by Sigma-Aldrich (catalog
#ALD00619).
The generalization of this fumarate-based BG approach is
illustrated in Table 1 using acid-free Minisci conditions on a
range of primary, secondary, and tertiary carboxylic acids.
Although these C-4-alkylated pyridines appear simple, it is
instructive to comment on the means by which such
compounds were previously prepared. In nearly all cases the
current method represents a more practical and cost-effective
solution. In the case of primary carboxylic acid adducts,
pyridine 11 was accessed from C-4-prefunctionalized 4-
methylpyridine via lithiation-SN2 with corresponding alkyl
bromide (ca. $105/g13b).14 Pyridine 12 was obtained through
an analogous sequence using an alkyl bromide containing a
protected alcohol requiring subsequent deprotection and
chlorination (ca. $945/g13b).15 Pyridines 13, 14, and 17
were previously prepared via photochemical addition on 4-
vinylpyridine.16 Pyridine 15 required a Pd-cross-coupling on
either 4-vinyl or 4-bromopyridine (Heck17a or Sonogashira,17b
respectively) followed by reduction (ca. $538/g13c). Similarly,
pyridine 16 can be accessed via reduction of the Heck product
of 4-vinylpyridine and an aryl iodide.18
Numerous secondary carboxylic acids were employed to
access such pyridines with high simplicity when placed in
context. For example, pyridine 8 has been prepared multiple
times, either leading to mixtures (e.g., Figure 1C) or requiring
C-4-prefunctionalized pyridines (ca. $584/g13d).19 Similarly,
pyridine 18 has been accessed from 4-bromopyridine through
photochemical and electrochemical reductive couplings or by
employing Hong’s BG (Figure 1B) and a Hantzsch ester
radical precursor10b (ca. $150/g13e). Pyridine 21 has been
accessed either via cross-coupling/hydrogenation20a or C-4-
selective Grignard addition using TBSOTf to generate a
transient BG and reoxidation20b (ca. $100/g13b). Cyclopropyl-
containing pyridine 23 was accessed either from 4-bromo or 4-
Bpin pyridine via Suzuki or Grignard addition/rearomatization
(ca. $226/g13a).21 The trivial cyclohexanone pyridine 25 has
only been accessed in a controlled fashion using multistep
routes with protecting groups and FG manipulations (ca.
$871/g13f).22
Many of the quaternary centers containing C-4-alkylated
pyridines (derived from tertiary carboxylic acids) prepared
here are new (29−33) and are likely desirable starting
materials for medicinal chemistry programs. Of the known
alkylated pyridines in this series, two were prepared as mixtures
of regioisomers using radical chemistry (26 and 28)23,24 or via
Minisci addition to 4-cyanopyridine.25
The chemistry outlined above is not limited to the parent
pyridine 6a but can also be employed on mono- (6b, 6d−i) or
bis- (6c) substituted pyridines. Pyridines 35, 39, and 41 are
new compounds and might be challenging to access
Figure 2. (A) Fumarate-derived blocking group for Minisci reaction
in the discovery stage. (B) The pyridinium 6a as an inexpensive
gateway to C-4-alkylated pyridine synthesis.
11928
J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2021, 143, 11927−11933