Organic Letters
Letter
At the outset, we focused on the use of halogenating agents, as
N-haloamines are readily prepared from the corresponding
primary amines and have been used in various trans-
formations.15 Our preliminary investigations revealed that the
halogen acts as a strong activating group; consequently, the
addition of various transition metals led to complex mixtures
details). Motivated by our recent identification that 4-
substituted isoxazolidin-5-ones,16 cyclic variants of O-acylhy-
droxylamines, serve as alkyl nitrene precursors suitable for Rh-
catalyzed C(sp3)−H insertions,17 we then turned our attention
to O-benzoylhydroxylamines: O-Bz hydroxylamines can also be
prepared from amines using benzoyl peroxide, a commercial
oxidant.18,19 Treatment of 1a, which was synthesized from 4-
phenylbutylamine, with 1 mol % Rh2(esp)2 in HFIP at an
ambient temperature led to the full consumption of the substrate
to afford pyrrolidine 2a in good yield (entry 1, Table 1). The
transformation was sluggish at lower temperature, and no
reaction occurred without the added catalyst, even at higher
temperature (entries 2, 3).
As O-Bz hydroxylamines were identified as suitable substrates
for the synthesis of pyrrolidines, the scope and limitations of the
current C(sp3)−H insertion reaction were investigated (Figure
1). In this study, products were isolated in their Boc-protected
forms for ease of purification. Depending on precursor
availability, O-Bz hydroxylamines 1 were synthesized directly
from the corresponding primary amines or the corresponding
alcohols by the Mitsunobu reaction with BocNHOBz, followed
by the removal of the Boc group. A wide range of 4-
arylbutylamine derivatives underwent C−H insertion at their
benzylic positions to afford pyrrolidines in good yields,
regardless of the electronic nature and position of the
substituent on the aromatic ring (2a−2g). The slower reaction
observed for ortho-substituted substrate 1g is likely due to an
unfavorable conformation for C−H insertion. In stark contrast,
heteroaryl-containing substrates were found to be unsuitable in
Not only does insertion into benzylic C−H bonds occur rapidly,
but also methine C−H bonds proved to be reactive, forming 2i
in good yield. Furthermore, unactivated methylene C−H bonds
underwent the rhodium-catalyzed pyrrolidine-forming reaction,
albeit with a slower rate (2j). Although the benzylic position
appears to be the preferred reaction site, its higher reactivity
cannot overcome the innate tendency of the current catalyst
system to form five-membered rings, as exemplified by the
exclusive formation of 2k. Moreover, the C−H bonds in a
terminal methyl group did not exhibit any reactivity under the
optimized conditions (2l). The successful cyclization of
hydroxylamine 1m derived from leelamine, a diterpene amine,
suggests the potential utility of the current protocol for the
derivatization of natural products and pharmaceuticals. The
scalability of the Rh-catalyzed C(sp3)−H amination was
demonstrated on a larger scale: The cyclization proceeded
with as little as a 0.1 mol % catalyst loading without
compromising the efficiency (eq 1).
through C(sp2)−H functionalization (Scheme 2). While similar
transformations have also been reported for more reactive O-Ts
hydroxylamines with20 or without21 rhodium catalysis, O-Bz
hydroxylamines did not react in the absence of the catalyst,
establishing the importance of generating the reactive electro-
philic nitrogen species in this system. Given the lack of
regioisomer formation, the cyclization likely proceeds from the
ortho carbon rather than the ipso carbon, followed by skeletal
rearrangement.22 The distinctive product distribution from
structurally related substrates, isoxazolin-5-ones and O-Bz
hydroxylamines, underscores the importance of leaving group
structures to determine the reactivity of resulting active species.
The observed higher reactivity at benzylic and methine C−H
bonds suggests a buildup of positive charge or the formation of a
radical at the reaction site. To better obtain mechanistic insight,
two experiments were conducted (Scheme 3). When mono-
deuterated substrate 5 was subjected to the optimized
conditions, a kinetic isotope effect (KIE) value of 4.0 was
measured (Scheme 3a); this value lies between that reported for
the reaction of an O-Ts hydroxylamines and Rh2(esp)2 (5.3),
which likely proceeds in a stepwise mechanism,14 and that
observed for sulfamate esters using similar Rh catalysts (1.9−
2.9), which likely proceeds in a concerted mechanism.23
Furthermore, a radical clock experiment did not produce any
cyclopropyl-opening products, which indicates that the reaction
proceeds in either a concerted or stepwise manner in which five-
membered ring formation involving radical recombination is
kinetically faster than cyclopropane ring opening (k25 °C 1.3 ×
108 s−1).24 While further evidence is required to draw a
conclusion, these divergent data may suggest that both the
singlet and triplet pathways are operative during the catalytic
cycle depending on the substrate structure.25
In conclusion, we have demonstrated that O-Bz hydroxyl-
amines serve as proficient alkyl nitrene precursors in the
presence of a rhodium catalyst. From a retrosynthetic
perspective, the current protocol offers an alternate route to
those involving other known alkylnitrene precursors, azides and
O-Ts hydroxylamines. The generated rhodium-nitrenes under-
go intramolecular C−H insertions without decomposition to
form various substituted pyrrolidines. Our experimental data
indicate that the structure of the nitrene precursor plays a role in
determining the nature of the underexplored reactive
intermediate. Development of asymmetric catalysts for the
synthesis of enantioenriched N-heterocycles is currently under-
way in our laboratory.
ASSOCIATED CONTENT
* Supporting Information
■
sı
The Supporting Information is available free of charge at
Experimental procedures and spectra for new compounds
AUTHOR INFORMATION
Corresponding Authors
■
Hidetoshi Noda − Institute of Microbial Chemistry (BIKAKEN),
Masakatsu Shibasaki − Institute of Microbial Chemistry
(BIKAKEN), Shinagawa-ku, Tokyo 141-0021, Japan;
When truncated O-Bz hydroxylamine 3 was employed as a
substrate, tetrahydroquinoline 4 was obtained in good yield
C
Org. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX