S. Altun et al. / Polyhedron 48 (2012) 31–42
41
between the HOMO and the LUMO gap of the Pc species. In that case,
metal center can be oxidized and reduced before the ring-based re-
dox processes. This type of Pc complexes can vary their electro-
chemical behaviour according to their environment, depending on
whether there are any available coordinating species that would
stabilize the Co(II) center. The main difference lies in whether the
metal or the ring is oxidized first. Donor solvents strongly favour
Co(III)Pc(-2) by coordinating along the axis to form six coordinate
species. If such solvents are absent, then oxidation to Co(III) is inhib-
ited and ring oxidation occurs first. Thus, the first oxidation and the
first reduction processes of 9 in DMSO/TBAP are probably metal-
based and correspond to Co(II)Pc(-2)/[Co(III)Pc(-2)]+ and Co(II)Pc
(-2)/[Co(I)Pc(-2)]À redox couples, respectively. On the other hand,
it is also well known from the literature that the second reduction
process is ring-based [39]. The peak currents of the last reduction
couple are much higher than those of the other redox couples, as ob-
served also for 10. This behaviour implies that it corresponds to the
reduction of four oxy-coumarin substituents. Spectroelectrochemi-
cal measurements were also carried out to assign especially the first
reduction and the first oxidation processes of 9 certainly. Fig. 8A
shows in situ UV–Vis spectral changes during the first reduction of
9 at À0.80 V versus SCE, corresponding to the redox process labelled
R1 in Fig. 7A. The split Q-band absorption in the UV–Vis spectrum of
9 in DMSO/TBAP confirms the presence of aggregated species. The
band with higher energy corresponds to the aggregated species
while the one with lower energy is attributed to the deaggregated
species. Upon the first reduction, the absorptions of both bands de-
crease with red shift, while a new band appears at 475 nm. The new
Q-band is considerably broad, suggesting that some singly reduced
species are still aggregated after the first reduction process. The
spectral changes form various isosbestic points at different wave-
lengths within the ranges of 683–713 nm and 563–573 nm, rather
than the ones at specific wavelengths, due to the formation of differ-
ent reduced species produced from reduction of aggregated and
monomer species of 9. The band at 475 nm and the shifting of the
Q-band indicate the formation of [Co(I)Pc(-2)]À species, confirming
the CV assignment of the couple R1 to Co(II)Pc(À2)/[Co(I)Pc(À2)]À
process [36–39]. During the second reduction at À1.50 V versus
SCE, the higher energy side of the broad Q-band at 687 nm decreases
while its lower energy side increases, and thus two new bands ap-
pear at 645 and 702 nm. These spectral changes are associated by
increase in the absorption within the range of 436–625 and thus,
the formation of a band at 492 nm (Fig. 8B). The changes are charac-
teristics for a ring-based reduction in Co(II)Pc complex, and thus,
confirm our voltammetric assignment of this process to [Co(I)Pc
(-2)]À/[Co(I)Pc(-3)]2À. Fig. 8C displays in situ UV–Vis spectral
changes during the first oxidation process at 0.55 V versus SCE.
The absorptions of both peaks of the Q-band decrease and a Q-band
with the wavelength maximum of 637 nm and a new band at
456 nm appears. The new Q-band is considerably broad, suggesting
that some singly oxidized species are still aggregated after the first
oxidation process. The formation of a new band at 456 nm is typical
of a metal-based oxidation in CoPc complexes and thus, confirms
the CV assignment of Co(II)Pc(-2)/[Co(III)Pc(-2)]+ for couple O1 of
9 in Fig. 7A [43–46]. The tetra-substituted analogue of 9 did not
form aggregated species in DMSO/TBAP, as stated in a recent report
[37]. It appears that the increase in the number of peripheral oxy-
coumarin substituents increases the extent of cofacial interactions
between the neighbouring CoPc molecules, and thus, causes H-type
aggregation.
one oxidation couple in DMSO/TBAP within the available potential
ranges. Due to the non-coordinating nature of DCM, the first oxida-
tion processes of 9 (O1) is probably ligand-based and corresponds
to Co(II)Pc(-2)/[Co(II)Pc(-1)]+ couple while the second one (O2) is
metal-based and may be attributed to [Co(II)Pc(-1)]+/[Co(III)Pc
(-1)]2+ couple [39]. Fig. 8D displays the UV–Vis spectrum of 9 in
DCM/TBAP and in situ spectral changes during its first oxidation
at 1.05 V versus SCE. The solution of complex 9 in DCM/TBAP does
not involve aggregated species as understood clearly from the nar-
row and nonsplit Q-band at 671 nm in this figure. Upon the first
oxidation, the absorptions of the sharp Q band at 671 nm and the
vibrational band at 604 nm decreases without shift and two new
Q bands at 526 and 755 nm develops. These spectral changes are
characteristic for a Pc-based oxidation and thus, lead to the forma-
tion of [Co(II)Pc(-1)]+ species [41,42]. Unfortunately, the electroly-
sis of 9 at the potentials more positive than 1.10 V versus SCE in
DCM/TBAP resulted in decomposition of the complex, as evidenced
from decrease in the absorption of all peaks.
4. Conclusions
The novel metal-free Pcs 5, 8 and metal Pcs 6, 7, 9 and 10 have
been prepared from 4-chloro-5-(4-(4-methoxyphenyl)-8-methyl-
coumarin-7-yloxy)phthalonitrile (3) and 4,5-bis(4-(4-methoxy-
phenyl)-8-methylcoumarin-7-yloxy)phthalonitrile (4). The
compounds were characterized by UV–Vis, IR and MALDI-
TOF mass spectrometry, and elemental analysis. The effect of
substituent (the coumarin and chloro), metal (Co and Zn), solvent
(DMSO, DCM, toluene and chloroform) and concentration on the
spectroscopic properties and aggregation behaviour of the novel
compounds were investigated. The compounds displayed high
aggregation tendency in DMSO whereas their aggregated species
were not observed in DCM, toluene and chloroform. The
compounds 8–10 showed redox processes located at the ring
and/or metal centre. The aggregation character of the compounds
in DMSO was reflected by splitting or broadening of the redox
waves while the compounds displayed well-defined voltammo-
grams in DCM, due to the absence of aggregated species in this sol-
vent. Furthermore, the nature of the redox processes and the effect
of aggregation on the electron transfer processes were identified by
in situ spectroelectrochemical measurements during controlled-
potential electrolysis of the complexes at suitable potentials.
Acknowledgments
We are thankful to The Foundation of Marmara University,
The Commission of Scientific Research (BAPKO) (Project No:
FEN-A-090909-0302 and FEN-C-DRP-080410-0091) and Turkish
Academy of Sciences (TUBA).
Appendix A. Supplementary data
Supplementary data associated with this article can be found, in
References
[1] M. Calvete, M. Hanack, Eur. J. Org. Chem. (2003) 2080.
[2] J. Sleven, C. Gorller-Walrand, K. Binnemas, Mater. Sci. Eng., C 18 (2001) 229.
[3] S.M. Gorun, J.W. Rathke, M.J. Chen, Dalton Trans. (2009) 1095.
[4] M.R. Christie, B.G. Freer, Dyes Pigm. 24 (1994) 113.
[5] M. Özer, A. Altındal, A.R. Özkaya, Ö. Bekarog˘lu, Dalton Trans. 17 (2009) 3175.
[6] Y. Açıkbasß, M. Evyapan, T. Ceyhan, R. Çapan, Ö. Bekarog˘lu, Sens. Actuators, B
135 (2009) 426.
[7] A. Wang, L. Long, C. Zhang, J. Incl. Phenom. Macrocycl. Chem. 71 (2011) 1.
[8] T. Goslinskia, J. Piskorzb, J. Photochem. Photobiol., C 12 (2011) 304.
[9] M. Pisßkin, M. Durmusß, J. Photochem. Photobiol., A 223 (1) (2011) 37.
In contrast to its behaviour in DMSO/TBAP, complex 9 shows
well-defined redox couples in DCM/TPAP (Fig. 7B), probably due
to the absence of aggregated species. The first reduction process
(R1) is metal-based and corresponds to Co(II)/Co(I) couple while
the other reduction processes are ligand-based [39]. Complex 9
displays two oxidation couples in DCM/TBAP while it shows only