ACS Medicinal Chemistry Letters
Letter
intermediates were coupled with D-tryptophan derivative 215 to
partially due to flexibility of the M460 side chain (which is not
resolved in the X-ray structure of T. brucei CYP51 complexed
with (S)-1) (Figure 1B). When (R)-2 is bound, the interactions
between M460 and the central phenyl ring of the inhibitor are
established and partially block the entrance to the active site
(Figure 2C).
provide the final compounds 3−8.20
As shown in Table 1 and Figure 2A, the potency of (R)-2 as
an inhibitor of T. cruzi in infected cells increased >1000-fold
compared to (S)-1, making (R)-2 the first pM inhibitor derived
from LP10. The new inhibitor (R)-2 retained good microsome
stability and had an acceptable profile for inhibition of human
CYPs.
The X-ray cocrystal structure of (R)-2 with T. cruzi CYP51
was determined to a resolution of 3.1 Å (PDB ID 4BY0) (See
Supporting Information for details). The diffraction data and
refinement statistics are shown in Table 2. Despite a relatively
On the basis of the TcCYP51-(R)-2 cocrystal structure, 17
hydrophobic amino acid residues, F48, Y103, I105, M106,
F110, Y116, P210, V213, F214, A287, F290, A291, T295, L356,
M358, M360, M460, and V461, constitute the binding site
within 5 Å of (R)-2 (Figure 3). No direct H-bonds between
(R)-2 and the TcCYP51 target are suggested by the cocrystal
structure, with the qualification that water molecules, which
might potentially mediate such contacts, may not be resolved at
3.1 Å. The amino acids I45, F48, I72, V213, L357, M358, and
M360 surround the terminal 3-fluorophenyl ring of (R)-2
(Figure 3), providing space to explore a variety of ring
substituents. By applying structure-based molecular design
considerations,21,22 a series of (R)-2 analogues were synthesized
with the objective to increase potency against T. cruzi.
Specifically, additional substituents on the terminal phenyl
ring were introduced to fill the hydrophobic pocket identified in
the cocrystal structure. In addition, a flexible piperazine ring
was inserted between the aromatic rings of the rigid biaryl unit
to probe binding interactions in the hydrophobic pocket
projecting toward the solvent accessible area. A diverse set of
new inhibitors was synthesized, among which (R)-3−(R)-8
(see Scheme 1 for syntheses of these compounds) are
particularly potent (Table 1). The (S)-enantiomers of several
of these and of other inhibitors were also synthesized and in all
cases were found to be considerably less potent than the
corresponding (R)-enantiomers (see Table S1 and Figure S2,
Supporting Information).
Table 2. X-ray Data Collection and Refinement Statistics
protein
inhibitor
PDB ID
T. cruzi CYP51
(R)-2 (small molecule code 5PS)
4BY0
Data Collection
space group
P3221
cell dimensions
a, b, c (Å)
124.2, 124.2, 119.8
α, β, γ (deg)
90.0, 120, 90.0
molecules in AU
wavelength
2
1.11587
3.10
resolution (Å)
Rsym or Rmerge (%)
I/σI
a
15.6 (134.3)
9.6 (1.5)
completeness (%)
redundancy
100.0 (100.0)
8.2 (8.4)
Crystallization Conditions
0.2 M ammonium sulfate
0.1 M Bis-Tris
pH 6.5
25% PEG 3350
The 3,4-difluoro analogue (R)-4 gained an order of
magnitude in potency compared to (R)-2, while potency of
the 2,5-analogue (R)-3 dropped an order of magnitude. The
potency gain by (R)-4 is likely due to hydrophobic interactions
between the 4-fluoro substituent and the side chain of F48
(Figure 3), which is otherwise missing from the electron
density. Increasing the size of the substituent from 4-fluoro in
(R)-4 to 4-trifluoromethyl in (R)-5 resulted in a ca. 600-fold
loss in potency, while its microsome stability and selectivity to
human CYP enzymes were significantly improved compared to
(R)-4. Insertion of a piperazine ring between the aryl groups
yielded (R)-6, which was only 4-fold less potent than (R)-2.
Both (R)-7 and (R)-8 with terminal fluorine-substituted benzyl
ethers maintained EC50 potency comparable to (R)-2 and (R)-
5, respectively. Two of these compounds, (R)-5 and (R)-8, had
substantially improved microsome stability compared to (R)-2,
and (R)-8 in particular had a substantially improved inhibition
profile vs human CYP enzymes (Table 1). The binding poses
of inhibitors were predicted by docking studies using Glide (see
Figure S3, Supporting Information, for details). The terminal
phenyl ring of (R)-6 fits well into the hydrophobic pocket near
to the biaryl ring of (R)-2. In addition, the benzyl moiety of
(R)-7 or (R)-8 is oriented toward the solvent accessible area or
the hydrophobic pocket, respectively.
Refinement
no. reflections
18756
R
work/Rfree (%)
23.2/29.7
no. atoms
protein
6663
86
heme
ligand
74
solvent
13
mean B value
B-factors
protein
78.2
81.4
62.0
72.0
52.1
heme
ligand
solvent
rmsd
bond lengths (Å)
bond angles (deg)
0.011
1.664
a
Values in parentheses are for highest resolution.
low resolution, electron density unambiguously defined (R)-2
in the active site (Figure 2B), indicating that the biaryl unit of
(R)-2 is oriented toward the hydrophobic tunnel that is utilized
by the tail of posaconazole (Figure 2C). (R)-2 is distinguished
by an L-shape in the active site of T. cruzi CYP51, while (S)-1 is
more linear (Figure 2D). The different binding modes of (S)-1
and (R)-2 affect the conformations of interacting amino acid
residues, thus changing the landscape of the CYP51 binding site
for the two compounds. The entrance from the solvent-
accessible area remains quite open when (S)-1 is bound,
In summary, a new series of 4-pyridinyl-based CYP51
inhibitors has been developed by using structure-guided
molecular design methodology. Starting with the cocrystal
structure of (S)-1 bound to T. brucei CYP51, we significantly
improved inhibitor potency by switching to the R-configuration
of the inhibitor scaffold. Compared to the S-enantiomer series,
D
dx.doi.org/10.1021/ml500010m | ACS Med. Chem. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX