1500
W. Ang et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 24 (2014) 1496–1501
Table 5
according to the literatures with appropriate revision (see Supple-
mentary material).18,19 Obviously, compound 22 and 24 are shown
to be highly potent against M. tuberculosis H37Rv.
Antimycobacterial activities (MIC), cytotoxicities (IC50) on vero cells andselectivity
index (SI) values for the bis-oxazolidinone compounds 22–25
MICa
(
lg/mL)
IC50
(lg/mL)
SIc
b
Compd
In some literatures, two oxazolidinone rings in a single mole-
cule are reported to exhibit non-selective antibacterial activity to
a panel of Gram-positive bacteria (not including M. tuberculosis
strains).20 In their work, the second oxazolidinone was tethered
to the aromatic C-ring part of Linezolid scaffold, which resulted
in rigid structure moieties. To the contrary, in our work a flexible
linker was involved in the connection of the second oxazolidinone
ring to the B-ring of Linezolid, expecting to possess better solubil-
ities for thus obtained bis-oxazolidinones. Thus obtained bis-oxa-
zolidinone compounds 22–25 exhibited excellent activities
against M. tuberculosis H37Rv with MIC values ranging from 0.125
22
23
24
25
0.125
0.25
0.125
0.25
>5000
63.62
19.08
>40,000
254
152
107.10
428
a
MIC is defined as minimal drug concentration of the well in which bacterial
growth is similar to that with only 10 CFU of bacteria inoculated. Identical values
were obtained for each compound in three replicates by visual investigation as
stated in the experimental section.
b
IC50 denotes half maximal inhibitory concentration.
SI is defined as the ratio of IC50 in mammalian cells/MIC against Mtb.
c
to 0.25 lg/mL. The encouraging results from the antitubercular
studies indicated that introduction of a second oxazolidinone ring
can significantly improve their selectivity and potency against M.
tuberculosis. Introduction of a third oxazolidinone ring does not
seem to take effect on enhancement of antitubercular activities,
which was illustrated by compound 28 with three oxazolidinone
in vitro cytotoxicity assays using monkey kidney Vero cells
(Table 5). All the tested drugs showed good safety profile, particu-
larly compound 22 with an IC50 value over 5000 lg/mL and selec-
tivity index over 40,000 (IC50 on Vero cells/MIC against H37Rv). The
relationship of cytotoxicity data and the compounds’ structure
suggest that even a minor structrual alteration, herein with or
without a methoxy group in the phenyl substituent at N-position
of the second oxazolidinone ring in the western part of the mole-
cules, or absolute configuration conversion, may severely affect
their biological effects.
In conclusion, twenty-six novel oxazolidinone or bis-oxazolidi-
none compounds have been synthesized, fully characterized and
evaluated for their antitubercular effects against the virulent stan-
dard H37Rv strain as well as the drug-resistant clinic isolates. Four
novel bis-oxazolidinone compounds were identified as potent
rings (MIC: 16
the N-position of the second oxazolidinone ring, also showed a
apparent loss of antitubercular activity (MIC: 8 g/mL) compared
lg/mL). Compound 26, lacked a phenyl group on
l
to compounds 22 and 24, which suggested that phenyl or substi-
tuted phenyl groups were essential to remain antitubercular activ-
ities. The removal of the first oxazolidinone ring in the eastern part
of compound 22 led to severe loss of antitubercular activity, where
compound 30 merely possessed an MIC value of 32 lg/mL. As a re-
sult, a preliminary body of structure–activity relationships (SARs)
was established (Fig. 2). Besides, it is also easy to find that more
lipophilic compounds with higher LogP values showed better anti-
tubercular activities except for the simplest mono-oxazolidione
compound 30.
agents with MIC values of 0.125–0.25 lg/mL to H37Rv. A prelimin-
ary body of structure–activity relationships (SARs) and property–
structure relationship was established. To date, researchers have
put great efforts on the expansion of antibacterial spectrum to
gram-negative bacteria of oxazolidinone compounds and obtained
some positive achievement. The agents with broad antimicrobial
agents surely can attenuate the symptoms of the patients who
have been infected with unknown microorganism, but these
agents may also bring the potential risk of aggravating antibiotic-
resistant bacteria epidemics. Here we found several bis-oxazolidi-
nones displayed excellent and highly selective activities to virulent
M. tuberculosis H37Rv with excellent safety profile on monkey kid-
ney Vero cells, especially for compound 22 with a selectivity index
over 40,000. Our results also envisioned an alternative consider-
ation to add new drug candidates to the well-established antibiotic
structural type with good species selection.
Listed in Table 4 are the MIC values of bis-oxazolidinone
compounds 22–25 against several clinical drug-resistant TB iso-
lates, including Isoniazid-resistant M. Tuberculosis, multi-drug
resistant M. Tuberculosis (MDR-TB) and extensive-drug resistant
M. Tuberculosis (XDR-TB). The major disappointment is that the
activity decreases 20 fold or more against MDR and XDR TB. These
relatively frustrating results against MDR and XDR TB of com-
pounds 22 and 24 compared to Linezolid drove us to go deeply into
the mechanism of resistance of the strains. As shown in Table 4,
Linezolid, an inhibitor of ribosomal protein synthesis, remained
its activities against the tested drug-resistant TB strains, which
suggest that the natural resistance of the MDR and XDR TB strains
to our bis-oxazolidinone compounds may be correlated to a mech-
anism of efflux pumps or other non-ribosomal alterations. This
non-ribosomal mechanism has been shown for Linezolid in M.
smegmatis mutants.21
Acknowledgments
To obtain insight into potential toxicities of the final bis-oxazo-
lidinone compounds, bis-oxazolidinone 22–25 were evaluated in
This work was supported by the National Major Program of Chi-
na during the 12th Five-Year Plan Period (2012ZX09103-101-036)
and New-Century Excellent Talent Fund by Ministry of Education
(NCET-13-0388). The authors are grateful to Dr. Zhenling Wang
in National Key Lab of Biotherapy and technician Jianying Tang in
Good doctor Pharmaceutical Company for the in vitro preliminary
screening of antibacterial activities on Staphylococcus aureus, Esch-
erichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The authors also express
their thanks to Dr. Ruiliang Jin in Shanghai Pulmonary Hospital
for in vitro antitubercular screening.
Supplementary data
Supplementary data (experiment section and spectrum data)
associated with this article can be found, in the online version, at
Figure 2. SAR of target compounds.