2354
H. Chen et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 24 (2014) 2353–2359
concentration (CC50) value of 183 lM. After the introduction of
methoxyl group into cinnamoyl group at the C-19 position, the
cytotoxicity of analogues 2b and 2c decreased obviously (CC50
>1970 and 1706 lM) compared with compound 2a, indicating that
the methoxyl group play a crucial role in reducing cytotoxicity. The
above conclusion was further supported by 19-O-(20-methoxy) nic-
otinyl analogue 2f with lower cytotoxicity than 19-O-nicotinyl
analogue 2e. Compound 2c with 3,4,5-trimethoxycinnamic group
at C-19 possessed noticeable inhibition on HBV DNA replication
15
15
O
O
16
C
8
14
O
HO
O
11
12
17
HO
3
A
B
3
HO
19
19
with the IC50 value of 10.3 lM and lower cytotoxicity resulting in
HO
HO
a SI value higher than 165.1, demonstrating that both m-methoxyl
and p-methoxyl groups could enhance activity against HBV DNA
replication. However, 19-O-(30-chloro) cinnamoyl analogue 2d
exhibited higher cytotoxicity and weaker activity due to the intro-
duction of halogen into the substituent. The heteroatomic rings at
C-19 position play an important role in suppressing HBV DNA rep-
lication and secretions of HBsAg and HBeAg in agreement with the
high activities of compounds 2e, 2g and 2h with the IC50 values of
1b
1a
Figure 1. Compounds 1a and 1b.
According to molecular hybridization principle,32 esterification
of natural compounds is an effective approach for achieving
promising derivatives, by which two active parts can be easily
hybridized to enhance activity. For example, a series of active
derivatives of caudatin15 and hemslecin A17 were obtained by
esterification in our previous investigations, which showed obvi-
ously enhanced activity compared with the parent compounds.
To increase anti-HBV activity and decrease cytotoxicity, derivatives
of dehydroandrographolide and andrographolide were obtained by
the Steglich esterification to incorporate cinnamoyl groups and
heterocyclic rings with nitrogen, oxygen and sulfur atom, which
offered appreciable inhibition of HBV DNA replication.6,7,33 Com-
pound 1a was esterified with acids in the presence of 4-dimethyl-
aminopyridine (DMAP) and N0,N0-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCC)
in anhydrous dichloromethane (Scheme 1). Generally, 19-O-subsi-
tuted derivatives were the main products; 3, 19-O-disubsituted
derivatives were obtained with low yields at the same time. Posi-
tions of the substituents can be determined by the changes of
the chemical shifts of H-3 and H-19 in 1H NMR spectrum. For
example, the chemical shifts of H-3 and H-19a of 19-O-substituted
derivative 2e appeared at dH 3.33 and 4.37 in contrast to dH 4.88
and 4.40 of 3, 19-O-disubstituted derivative 3a. When compound
1b was treated under the Steglich esterification conditions, deriva-
tives 4a–6f were obtained by losing hydroxyl group at C-14 and
forming carbon–carbon double bond between C-14 and C-15
(Scheme 2).28 Other acylation products 2j, 3d–3g, 4g, 5g, 6c, 6e
and 6f were achieved with anhydrides and catalytic amount of
DMAP in anhydrous pyridine. Compounds 1a and 1b were treated
under Pfitzner–Moffatt oxidation condition with DCC, dimethyl
sulfoxide (DMSO), trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) in anhydrous pyridine
and dichloromethane to reveal effects of transforming hydroxyl
groups at C-3 and C-19 into carbonyl groups (Scheme 3). On the
ring C, compounds 9a and 9b were obtained in the presence of
formaldehyde or acetone under sodium carbonate (Scheme 4). To
investigate the influence of lactone ring on anti-HBV activity, com-
pound 1b was dealt with sodium hydroxide in water to obtain
product 10 with lactone ring opened. On the ring B, carbon–carbon
double bond between C-8 and C-17 was epoxidized by the m-chlo-
roperoxybenzoic acid (m-CPBA) in dichloromethane at room tem-
perature to produce compound 11.34 The purity (higher than
90%) of all the derivatives was determined by HPLC (normalization
method with no obvious impurity peak) or TLC with three different
solvent systems (only one spot under UV detection and sprayed
with 10% H2SO4).
22.1, 9.3 and 22.1 lM. In contrast to 19-O-substituted analogues,
the 3, 19-O-disubstituted compounds 3a–3g showed dramatic de-
crease of anti-HBV activity resulting from the disubstituents at C-3,
and C-19.
For further investigation, 23 andrographolide derivatives were
obtained. 19-O-Cinnamoyl and 19-O-(30,40,50-trimethoxy) cinnam-
oyl derivatives 4a and 4b exhibited increased activity with the
IC50 values of 46.58 and 22.25 lM against HBV DNA replication.
19-O-Nicotinoyl (4c), 19-O-20-furoyl (4d) and 19-O-20-thenoyl
(4e) derivatives showed significant inhibition on HBV DNA replica-
tion with higher SI values of 126.0, 100.5, and 104.9, and lower
cytotoxicity than derivatives 2e, 2g and 2h with the same substit-
uents, inferring that the cytotoxicity of these derivatives is closely
related to the conjugated double bonds between C-12 and C-15 or
C-11 and C-14. According to the principle of bioisosteric replace-
ment, 19-O-benzoyl analogue 4f was prepared and exhibited sim-
ilar activity against HBV DNA replication with the IC50 value of
20.6 lM and lower SI value compared with compounds 4c, 4d
and 4e, indicating that heteroatomic rings containing N, O and S
are profitable for decreasing cytotoxicity. In contrast to 19-O-vale-
ryl analogue 4h, the obviously enhanced activity of 19-O-acetyl
analogue 4g suggested that the length of alkyl chain could influ-
ence the anti-HBV activity. Compounds 2a–2j and 4a–4g showed
different cytotoxicity, suggesting that the conjugated double bonds
are closely related to their cytotoxicity but varied with the substit-
uents at C-19. The high cytotoxicity of 3-O-substituted ones (5a–
5h) indicated that the substituent at C-19 and free hydroxyl group
at C-3 are necessary for maintaining low cytotoxicity. Among 3, 19-
disubstituted derivatives, 3, 19-O-disuccinyl (6e) and 3, 19-O-di
(20-carboxyl) benzoyl (6f) analogues exhibited the improvement
of activity, which indicated the importance of free carboxyl group
for anti-HBV activity.
In comparison with oxidative products 7a, 8a and 8b, the IC50
value of compound 7b was improved to 13.4 lM due to the pres-
ence of a free hydroxyl group at C-3. The decreased activity of
derivatives 9a and 9b supported the importance of methylene at
C-15. Derivative 10 with the lactone ring opened showed the
similar activity and cytotoxicity to the parent compound 1b, sug-
gesting that the lactone ring plays little role in anti-HBV activity.
Double bond between C-8 to C-17 in ring B was indispensable
owing to the reduced inhibition on HBV DNA replication of epoxide
11.
Although dehydroandrographolide 1a and andrographolide 1b
were inactive against the secretions of HBsAg and HBeAg, 14
derivatives with inhibitory activity on HBsAg secretion and 19
derivatives inhibited HBeAg secretion were obtained. Compounds
2a, 4e and 9a inhibited HBsAg secretion with the SI values in the
range of 10.2–20.3, and compounds 2h and 4e suppressed HBsAg
Derivatives of dehydroandrographolide (1a) and andrographo-
lide (1b) were evaluated for their anti-HBV activity, namely inhib-
iting the secretions of HBsAg and HBeAg, and HBV DNA replication
on HepG 2.2.15 cells in vitro with tenofovir as the positive con-
trol.13 The anti-HBV activity and cytotoxicity were summarized
in Table 1.
19-O-Cinnamoyl analogue 2a showed high activity against HBV
DNA replication with IC50 value of 14.6 lM and 50% cytotoxicity