J. Elkaim et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 24 (2014) 2512–2516
2515
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
released LDH
total LDH
24 h
48 h
Figure 4. Total LDH and LDH release in the culture medium after treatment of HL60 cells with compound 1.
Table 2
treatment of HL60 cells with compound 1 was measured, using
doxorubicin as positive control (Table 1).
FACS analysis of HL60 cells treated with compound 1 for 24 h
SubG1
G0/G1
S phase
G2/M
After 24 h, caspase 3 activity was dose-dependently activated
by treatment with compound 1, with a 3-fold increase at 50 lM.
Thus compound 1 is able to stimulate apoptosis through the acti-
vation of caspase 3.
However the moderate activation of the caspase 3 cannot
account for the whole cytotoxic effect of compound 1. Therefore,
the release of cytosolic LDH into the culture medium as a marker
for cell necrosis was also measured (Fig. 4).
HL60 24 h
Doxo 50 nM
1.2
1.8
2.7
10.9
69.5
47.6
14.5
48.3
46.8
14.7
48.7
34.4
44.7
34.4
14.6
2.5
49.3
4.3
8.0
1.3
1 5
l
M
1 20
1 50
l
l
M
M
DNA was tagged with propidium iodide and results expressed as the percentage of
cells in the different phases of cell cycle.
After 24 h, the total LDH activity was not noticeably modified
indicating that the cell number was unaffected at that time.
However, compound 1 induced a clear release of LDH into the
by competing with ATP, in agreement with the in silico experi-
ments and chemical design work.
By contrast, compounds 3 and 4 did not show significant inhibi-
tion, while being structurally related. From these very informative
results, we tentatively established a preliminary structure–activity
culture medium at concentrations above 20 lM indicating that
cells entered the necrotic process. After 48 h, a dose-dependent
decrease of total LDH paralleled the cytotoxic effect of com-
pound 1 while the release of LDH remained observable. In the
same conditions, 1 lM doxorubicin elicited a reduction in the
relationship. The calculated Ki of 4.5 and 9 lM for compounds 1
total LDH content without any discernible leakage of the cyto-
solic LDH. Therefore we can conclude that necrosis is involved
in the cell death mode of compound 1. Finally, a possible effect
of compound 1 on cell division was investigated. As shown in
Table 2, doxorubicin promoted an early blockade of the cell cycle
in phase G2/M. Compound 1 did not block the cell cycle but pro-
moted a direct and dose-dependent accumulation of dead cells
(SubG1 phase). This is in line with the cytotoxic effect of com-
pound 1 in the non-dividing cell line EPC demonstrating that
compound 1 could promote cell death irrespective of the cell
cycle.
Guided by the information obtained from the initial virtual
screening, a series of original molecules was synthesized and eval-
uated for their effect on Pontin and potential anti-cancer activity.
Among the four selected candidates from the docking process, only
compounds 1 and 2 displayed a comparable effect on Pontin ATP-
ase activity. However, only compound 1 displayed a cytotoxic
effect, while compound 2 had no noticeable effect on cell growth.
This lack of activity of compound 2 could result from cell perme-
ability constraint, or instability. Further measures of the biological
activity of compound 1 emphasized the induction of apoptotic cell
death together with necrosis. This latter effect could be directly
related to the cellular balance of ATP regulation. With this new
lead in hand, we are working on the establishment of a structure
activity-relationship in order to find agents with lower IC50. Paral-
lel to this study, is the search for a deeper understanding of the
mechanism of action on the biological target.
and 2, respectively, suggested that the 3-hydroxy-5-phenyl-2-pyri-
done moiety was more suited for the inhibitory activity than the 3-
hydroxy-2-quinolone core. Moreover, the absence of inhibition
observed for compounds 3 and 4 in the enzymatic assay high-
lighted the crucial role of the
a
-aminoamide function (R1–NH–
CO–CH(NH2)–R2), characteristic of compounds 1 and 2, for the
interaction with the catalytic center.
Cell culture, cell proliferation assay, cell cycle analysis, flow
cytometric detection of apoptosis, caspase activity assay and
necrosis assay were performed as previously detailed.35 Only com-
pound 1 demonstrated an antiproliferative activity in cancer cell
lines at 10À5 M (Fig. 2). IC50 of 9 and 15
lM were measured respec-
tively for KB and HL60 cells after 72 h of exposure. The other syn-
thesized molecules displayed no cytotoxic activity, including
compound 2 despite its ability to partially inhibit Pontin ATPase
activity in vitro. Compound 1 also reduced cell numbers with an
IC50 of 25
effect.
lM in the non-dividing EPC cells, suggesting a cytotoxic
The mode of action of compound 1 in HL60 cells was then inves-
tigated in more detail. First, apoptosis was evaluated with annexin
and 7-AAD labeling using FACS analysis. A dose-dependent cell
apoptosis was evidenced in HL60, demonstrating an early cell
death after 24 h of exposure at a concentration of 20
l
M, increas-
ing at 48 h. At 50
24 h (Fig. 3).
lM, compound 1 induced 95% of cell death at
As it is generally assumed that caspase 3 is the terminal effector
in the apoptotic cascade pathway, the activation of caspase 3 after