Table 1. Efficiency of ring expansion with various acids.
2 and 2’ depending on the nature of proton sources. Schçll-
kopf and Magnus showed that a selective O-protonation fol-
lowed by spontaneous rearrangement of the O-protonated
diazo compounds, providing epoxides related to 4 [Eq. (4)].
In contrast, Aggarwal observed a selective C-protonation
with methanol. Based on these observations, we predicted
that 2 and 2’ would undergo a selective C-protonation with
methanol to generate 5, which upon another protonation
with a stronger acid at the carbenic carbon would provide
ring-expanded product 6a [Eq. (5)].
To test this hypothesis, we screened various proton sour-
ces that have their pKa values ranging from 2.9
(ClCH2CO2H) to 16.5 (MeOH) to gain information about
their effects on the O- versus C-protonation and the subse-
quent ring expansion. From a series of experiments, a strong
correlation between the acidity of the proton sources and
the ratio of 4 and 6a has emerged (Figure 1). In general, the
formation of ring-expanded product 6a increases whereas
that of epoxide 4 decreases as the pKa value of the proton
source increases.[12]
Entry
Acid/conditions
Yield 4 [%][a]
Yield 6a [%][a]
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
H3CCO2H/CH2Cl2
F3CCO2H/CH2Cl2
Cl3CCO2H/CH2Cl2
HCl/aq THF
BF3·OEt2/CH2Cl2
SnCl4/CH2Cl2
27
0
63
37
49
45
27
47
47
78
84
trace
trace
0
trace
trace
3
TiCl4/CH2Cl2
Sm
ACHTUGNERTN(NUNG OTf)3/CH2Cl2
silica gel/THF
0
[a] Isolated yields; diazo compound 5 was generated by aqueous workup
and used without purification.
silica gel-promoted ring expansion (Table 2). Cyclohexanone
derivatives with a carbon- (1a–e) and heteroatom-based
(1 f) substituent at the C4 position (entry 1–6), piperidinones
1g–h (entries 7–8) and tetrahydropyranone 1i (entry 9) un-
derwent smooth ring-expansion to the corresponding seven-
membered ketones in respectable yields. Adamantanone 1j
also afforded the homologated product 6j in 85% yield
(entry 10). 3-Phenyl cyclobutanone 1k behaved similarly,
and provided the ring expanded product 3-phenyl cyclopen-
tanone 6k in 71% yield (entry 11).
Having established good methylene homologation with
symmetrical ketones, we next examined the selectivity for
unsymmetrical cyclic ketones containing substituent at the
a- and/or b-carbon (Table 3). Complete regioselectivity was
found for selected five to seven membered cyclic ketones.
Among five membered ketones, a-indanone 1l underwent
highly regioselective ring expansion, providing only b-tetra-
lone 6l in 67% yield (entry 1). This selectivity is in line with
the higher migratory aptitude of an aromatic carbon than
aliphatic carbon in a typical process developing cationic
characters along the reaction. On the other hand, two ste-
roids, estrone 1m and formestane 1n, afforded ring-expand-
ed homosteroid products, 6m and 6n, in 86 and 73% yield,
respectively, with exclusive migration of the less substituted
C16 methylene carbon over the more substituted C13 qua-
ternary carbon (entries 2 and 3). The identity of 6m and 6n
was further confirmed by their single crystal X-ray diffrac-
tion analysis.[14] For comparison to the homologation proto-
col developed by Kingbury,[7b] the two homosteroids 6m and
Figure 1. Relationship of the formation of epoxide and ring-expanded
ketone relative to the acidity of proton donors.
To further improve the efficiency for the formation of end
product 6a while minimizing epoxide 4, the ring expansion
behavior of isolated C-protonated diazo compound 5 was in-
vestigated. Assuming that a variety of Brønsted and Lewis
acids will potentially promote the rearrangement, we exam-
ined a set of readily available Brønsted and Lewis acids.
Most of these acids promote the desired ring expansion, but
their efficiency varies significantly (Table 1). Among the
acids examined, SmACHTUNGTRENNUNG(OTf)3 and silica gel stood out, yet silica
gel turned out to be the best reagent. With silica gel as a
proton source and a promoter for ring expansion, the high-
est yield of 6a was realized, and the formation of epoxide 4
was minimized. In a typical experiment, treatment of ketone
1 with LTMSD at À788C, followed by quenching with
MeOH and subsequent purification on silica gel afforded
ring expansion product 6a in 87% yield.[13]
Next, we explored the methylene homologation of a vari-
ety of symmetrical cyclic ketones by applying the protocol
involving MeOH quench at low temperature followed by
6n were homologated with catalytic ScACTHNUTRGENUG(N OTf)3, with 70 and
45% yield, respectively. As expected, a-tetralone 1o and a-
benzylidene cyclohexanone 1p provided the ring-expansion
products 6o and b-benzylidene cycloheptanone 6p with ex-
clusive sp2-carbon migration (entries 4 and 5). a,b-Epoxycy-
clohexanone derivative 1q also afforded single product 6q
through unsubstituted methylene migration (entry 6). a-Sub-
stituted cycloheptanone derivatives 1r and 1s also provided
&
2
&
ꢀ 2012 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Chem. Eur. J. 0000, 00, 0 – 0
ÝÝ
These are not the final page numbers!