.
Angewandte
Communications
DOI: 10.1002/anie.201300608
À
C F Activation
Catalytic Hydrodefluorination of Fluoromethanes at Room
Temperature by Silylium-ion-like Surface Species**
Mike Ahrens, Gudrun Scholz, Thomas Braun,* and Erhard Kemnitz*
À
Breaking C F bonds catalytically under moderate reaction
conditions can be considered a fundamental challenge in
synthetic chemistry.[1] The conversions can provide new
reaction pathways to otherwise unaccessible fluorinated
compounds and building blocks.[2] From an environmental
point of view, the defluorination of (poly)fluorinated com-
pounds is also of considerable interest because of the “super-
greenhouse gas” behavior of chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs),
hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), and perfluorocarbons (PFCs).[3]
Although significant progress was made for the intermolec-
ular activation of highly fluorinated aromatics and olefins,[1]
Jones et al., by using [Cp*2ZrH2] under an H2 atmosphere for
the hydrodefluorination of CH2F2,[9] and by Mikami et al. for
the a-difluoromethylation of lithium enolates when using
CHF3 as the difluoromethylation agent.[10] Some heteroge-
À
neous catalysts were developed and are capable of C F
activation of fluoromethanes at elevated temperature in the
gas phase. Thus, aluminum, transition-metals, and alkaline-
earth-metal oxides,[3a,11] sulfated metal oxides,[3a,11b] or metal
phosphates[3a] are able to catalyze the decomposition of
fluoromethanes to yield metal fluorides and carbon oxides, or
result in the hydrolysis of fluoromethanes at 250–8508C.
Recently, it was shown that CHF3 can be mineralized by solid
alkali hydroxides to give the corresponding fluorides, CO, and
À
C F bond cleavage reactions of fluorinated alkanes are less
developed. Major achievements include the employment of
silylium or alumylium ions as homogeneous Lewis-acidic
catalysts, which are stabilized by weakly coordinating
anions.[4] In the presence of hydrogen sources such as tertiary
silanes, the hydrodefluorination of highly fluorinated, but not
perfluorinated alkanes, was achieved under exceptionally
mild reaction conditions.[4b,c] Carbocationic species are dis-
cussed as intermediates, and in the presence of aromatic
À
H2O at moderate temperatures. An initial C H interaction is
considered as the crucial reaction step.[12] Mass spectrometric
experiments revealed that lanthanide cations can react with
CH3F in the gas phase, whereas no reaction was found for
[13]
CHF3 and CF4.
À
Herein we report on the heterogeneous C F activation of
fluoromethanes in solution with nanoscopic aluminum
chlorofluoride (ACF) in the presence of Et3SiH. ACF is an
amorphous chlorine-containing aluminum fluoride AlClxF3Àx
(x ꢀ 0.05–0.3) and is considered to be a Lewis acid with an
À
compounds Friedel–Crafts products were generated. A C F
bond cleavage step or even a hydrodefluorination of fluoro-
methanes has so far not been reported with these catalytic
[14]
À
systems. Note, that for a homolytic cleavage, the C F bond
acidity comparable to SbF5. Catalytic experiments under
strengths in poly- and perfluorinated alkanes are less
very mild reaction conditions led either to hydrodefluorina-
tion or, in the presence of benzene, Friedel–Crafts-type
reactions. The conversions are presumably mediated by
compared to those in polyfluorinated methanes.[5] This bond
À
strength has to be considered as one reason for the C F bond
cleavage of polyfluorinated methanes being considerably
more difficult. However, for breaking a C F bond heterolyti-
cally, C2F6 would have a higher bond dissociation energy than
À
a silylium-ion-like surface species which initiates the C F
activation step.
À
In an initial experiment ACF was treated with Et3SiH in
benzene. A 19F NMR spectrum of the reaction solution
revealed the formation of small amounts of Et3SiF. 19F Hahn
spin-echo MAS NMR studies showed that weakly bound
surface fluorine species, which were present at the ACF
before treatment with Et3SiH, vanished after the contact with
the silane (see Figure S1 in the Supporting Information).
Because of the small amounts of the formed Et3SiF, it was not
possible to identify any hydride species on the solid surface by
MAS NMR spectroscopy. Nevertheless, the 1H MAS NMR
spectrum revealed broad signals for surface-bound Et3SiH
(Figure 1a). The immobilized Et3SiH species were also
detected by 29Si{1H} CP MAS NMR spectroscopy. We pre-
sume that Et3SiH reacts with the Lewis-acidic sites of ACF to
[6]
CF4. In addition, increasing fluorine content leads to
À
a substantial strengthening of each C F bond in fluorinated
methanes.[1a,7] Remarkably, Goldman et al. reported stoichio-
À
metric C F activation reactions of CH3F and CHF3 with an
iridium pincer compound.[8] In these cases, an initial C H
À
À
activation step is required to achieve a net C F activation.
Stoichiometric C Factivation reactions were also reported by
À
[*] Dr. M. Ahrens, Priv.-Doz. Dr. G. Scholz, Prof. Dr. T. Braun,
Prof. Dr. E. Kemnitz
Department of Chemistry, Humboldt-Universitꢀt zu Berlin
Brook-Taylor-Str. 2, 12489 Berlin (Germany)
E-mail: thomas.braun@chemie.hu-berlin.de
À
give a surface bound entity ACF···H SiEt3 (Figure 1b), which
[**] We thank the DFG (German Research Foundation) for financial
support and funding of the Research Training Group 1582 “Fluorine
as a Key Element”. M.A. thanks the Fonds der Chemischen Industrie
for additional financial support. Dr. Thoralf Krahl is kindly
acknowledged for the synthesis of a batch sample of ACF.
has considerable silylium ion character. Note that the result-
ing particles are not active anymore in the isomerization of
1,2-dibromohexafluoropropane into 2,2-dibromohexafluoro-
propane, whereas ACF catalyzes this isomerization at room
temperature.[15]
Supporting information for this article is available on the WWW
5328
ꢀ 2013 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2013, 52, 5328 –5332