T. Atallah et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 54 (2013) 5795–5798
5797
Table 1
Recovered carbonates and amines from the reaction of rac-3 with one-half equivalent of PhCH2NH2 using rhodium catalystsa
Rac-3
Catalyst
% ee of Recovered carbonateb
Amine
% Yield of aminec
% ee of Amined
89e
[a]
a
b
c
d
e
a
b
c
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
49
48
44
48
42
4a
4b
4c
4d
4e
4a
4b
4c
39
43
40
32
41
f
—
96
95g
f
—
+11.4
+8.4
+7.0
d
e
a
b
c
B
B
4d
4e
+8.8
+16.8
ꢀ11.9
ꢀ8.9
ꢀ7.8
ꢀ9.8
ꢀ17.7
ent-B
ent-B
ent-B
ent-B
ent-B
ent-4a
ent-4b
ent-4c
ent-4d
ent-4e
d
e
a
ent-A is not available commercially. Work in our laboratory and the Pfizer laboratory5d has shown that the two catalysts in Figure 1 give the same results within
experimental error.
b
From GC analysis of corresponding alcohols using a chiral column; major enantiomer has the R absolute configuration.
c
Isolated yield of 50% is theoretical.
d
Amines 4 have the S absolute configuration,12 which was confirmed by X-ray analysis of the (S)-(+)-mandelic acid salts of 4b and 4c.
e
Ref.5d
f
Poorly resolved on chiral HPLC columns.
From HPLC analysis of the Marfey derivatives of 4d and ent-4d.
g
NHCH2Ph
OCO2CH3
of configuration is the result of two inversions as has been previ-
ously shown for rhodium4b- and iridium-catalyzed allylic substitu-
tion reactions.1d A more detailed mechanism consistent with these
observations is shown in Scheme 3.
NHCH2Ph
B
ent-B
Ph
Ph
+
Ph
4a
[α] = +11.4o
ent-4a
PhCH2NH2
[α] = -11.9o
The pathway for the conversion of carbonates 3 to amines 4
proceeds through a matched enyl complex with catalyst A or B,
which makes this pathway faster than the one for the ent-3 to
ent-4 conversion in which a mismatched complex forms. The high
yield of 4 from the reaction of rac-3 with one-half equivalent of
benzylamine is the result then of a kinetic resolution which re-
quires that the reaction of the matched enyl complex with benzyl-
amine be faster than the rate of isomerization of the two enyl
Scheme 2. Reaction of rac-3a with one-half equivalent of PhCH2NH2 using catalyst
B and its enantiomer, ent-B.12
catalyst A. High % ee’s are obtained from several of these amines,
and crystal structures of 4a,5d 4b, and 4c establish the S absolute
configuration. Reaction of the five carbonates of rac-3 separately
with one-half equivalent of benzylamine was also carried out using
catalyst B and its enantiomer, (S,S,R,R)-Duanphos-Rh (catalyst ent-
B),12 as shown in Scheme 2 for rac-3a. As expected, the specific
rotation of +11.4° for 4a13 is almost identical to the +11.2° rotation
that is obtained when this amine is made using catalyst A. The spe-
cific rotations of 4a–e and ent-4a–e in Table 1 show that carbon-
ates rac-3a–e react with one-half equivalent of benzylamine in
the presence of these catalysts to generate amines with retention
of configuration. The data in Table 1, along with the linear Ham-
mett plot in Figure 3, are strong evidence that a common mecha-
nism is operative in the competitive reaction in Eq. 2.
complexes via a
pꢀ
r p
process or metal–metal displacement.4c
ꢀ
The matched enyl complex is presumably formed in two steps
from 3. Which step occurs first is open to speculation, but it seems
unlikely that they would occur simultaneously. Given the small,
positive
q value of +0.36, either of the two inversion steps in the
pathway from 3 to 4 could be rate-determining. Backside displace-
ment at the benzylic carbon in 3 via an electron pair on Rh or N
would be expected to increase the electron density in the transi-
tion step resulting in a positive
q value. Theoretical work by Stre-
itwieser et al., led them to conclude that electron-withdrawing
groups lower the barriers of ionic SN2 reactions.14
The observation that the reaction in Eq. 2 goes faster as the sub-
stituents become more electron-withdrawing gives more clarity to
the mechanism in Scheme 1. The small, positive slope of +0.36 for
The mechanism in Scheme 3 also accounts for the relatively low
ee’s for the recovered carbonates in Table 1. If the reaction of the
mismatched enyl complex with benzylamine is slow enough to
q
in the Hammett plot is consistent with a rate-determining step
make the
p
ꢀ
r
ꢀ
p rearrangement competitive, some ent-3 would
(RDS) which has a transition state that is electron rich relative to
its reactant(s). It is reasonable to assume that the overall retention
be converted to 3 resulting in a low ee for the carbonates in the
PhH2C
+NH2
PhH2C
NH
Rh(I)
+
LG
Rh
NHCH2Ph
LGRh(I)
Rh(I)
PhCH2NH2
inv.
Rh(I)
-Rh(I)
-Rh(I)
R
R
R
R
R
R
R
+
inv.
+
+
LG-
3
LG-
4
CO2/CH3OH
"matched" enyl complex
LG = OCO2CH3
π−σ−π
Rh(I) = catalyst A or B
PhH2C
PhH2C
+
LG
Rh
NHCH2Ph
+NH
NH
+
2 Rh(I)
Rh(I)
Rh(I)
LG
PhCH2NH2
inv.
Rh(I)
R
R
R
R
+
R
+
inv.
LG-
LG-
ent-3
ent-4
CO2/CH3OH
"mismatched" enyl complex
Scheme 3. Proposed mechanism for the reaction of rac-3 with benzylamine using A or B as the Rh(I) catalyst.