S. Bensaid, H. Doucet / C. R. Chimie 17 (2014) 1184–1189
1185
1. Introduction
pentan-1-ol, cyclopentylmethylether (CPME) and diethyl-
carbonate, which are among the ‘‘preferred’’ solvents [15].
The synthesis of arylated heteroaromatics is an
important field for research in organic synthesis due to
the physical or biological properties of these compounds.
In 1990, Ohta et al. reported that the direct arylation of
several heteroaromatics with aryl halides proceed in
moderate to good yields using Pd(PPh3)4 as the catalyst
and DMA (N,N-dimethylacetamide) as the solvent [1]. Since
these very innovative results, the Pd-catalysed direct
arylation of heteroaromatics with aryl halides or pseudo-
halides has been demonstrated to be an extremely
powerful method for the synthesis of a variety of arylated
heterocycles in a few steps [2]. This reaction provides a
cost-effective access to such compounds. Moreover, the
major wastes of the reaction are a base associated with HX
and the reaction solvent, instead of metallic salts produced
under classical cross-coupling procedures, such as Suzuki,
Negishi or Stille reactions [3]. The method avoids the
preliminary preparation of an organometallic compound,
reducing the number of steps necessary to prepare these
compounds. However, these coupling reactions are gen-
erally performed using large amounts of relatively toxic
solvents, such as DMA, DMF, NMP, or dioxane [4–6]. In
recent years, a few solvents that can be considered as
‘‘greener’’[7] according to P. Anastas’ principles have been
employed for direct arylations [8]. For example, Greaney
and Djakovitch reported that, using water as a solvent, the
direct arylation of oxazoles, thiazoles, indazoles, or indoles
The use of CPME as a solvent presents several
advantageous features, such as a high hydrophobicity.
Its limited miscibility in water allows an easy separation
and recovery from water. Another preferable characteristic
is the low formation of peroxides compared to THF or
diisopropyl ether. Moreover, CPME can be manufactured
by the addition of MeOH to cyclopentene, which produces
no apparent waste [16]. Pentan-1-ol is not considered a
hazardous air-pollutant solvent, is readily biodegradable
and practically non-toxic to fish and aquatic organisms.
Pentan-1-ol can be prepared by the reduction of 1-
valeraldehyde with hydrogen or by fermentation and is
present in cider, beer or wine to varying degrees. Therefore,
exposure to residual amounts of this alcohol is unlikely to
have any adverse health effects. Diethylcarbonate is a
polar, aprotic, non-toxic, and biodegradable solvent
[17]. Based on these properties, it also offers an envir-
onmentally friendly alternative to standard polar solvents.
Therefore, the use of CPME, pentan-1-ol or diethylcarbo-
nate as solvents is in agreement with the principles 1, 5 and
12 of ‘‘green chemistry’’ [7].
We have recently reported that the phosphine-free
Pd(OAc)2 catalyst promotes very efficiently the direct
arylation of some heteroaromatics in DMA [18]. We
initially employed this phosphine-free procedure in order
to determine the influence of the amount and nature of the
solvent for Pd-catalysed direct arylations. A first set of
reactions using thiophene 2-carbonitrile (0.75 mmol) and
4-bromoacetophenone (0.5 mmol) as the coupling part-
ners was carried out under previously reported reaction
conditions [18], but in 4, 1 or 0.5 mL of solvent with only
0.1 mol% Pd(OAc)2 catalyst (Table 1, column 3). In the
presence of polar solvents, DMA, NMP and DMF, high
conversions of 4-bromoacetophenone and yields of cou-
pling product 1 were obtained (Table 1, entries 1–3, 5–7
and 9–11 in column 3). The use of 0.1 mL of these three
solvents (concentration 5 M) and again 0.1 mol% Pd(OAc)2
catalyst led to lower conversion rates of 4-bromoaceto-
phenone of 36, 30 and 66% (Table 1, entries 4, 8 and 12 in
column 3). Then, we employed 0.1–4 mL of pentan-1-ol,
diethylcarbonate or CPME as the solvent and again
0.1 mol% Pd(OAc)2 catalyst. In all cases, poor conversions
of 4-bromoacetophenone were obtained (Table 1, entries
13–24 in column 3). The use of a higher catalyst loading of
0.5 mol% Pd(OAc)2 catalyst was found to increase the
conversion of 4-bromoacetophenone for the reactions
performed in 0.1 mL of DMA or NMP (Table 1, entries 4 and
8 in column 4), whereas it was not profitable for reactions
performed in pentan-1-ol and less profitable for reactions
performed in diethylcarbonate (Table 1, entries 14–16, 19,
and 20 in column 4). With this ligand-free catalyst, under
higher palladium concentrations, the so-called ‘‘palladium
black’’ forms more rapidly when pentan-1-ol or diethyl-
carbonate are used as the solvents. Therefore, the
concentration of active palladium species is not increased,
and the conversions of 4-bromoacetophenone are not
improved. This ligand-free procedure has to be employed
only with solvents that display coordination properties
with palladium. Therefore, in order to obtain higher yields
´
proceeds nicely [9]. Rene and Fagnou employed a mixture
of water and EtOAc for the direct arylation of thiophenes
[10a]. Polyethylene glycol (PEG 20000) has been found to
promote the direct arylation of triazoles [10b]. Carbonates,
ethers or alcohols have also been successfully employed
for the direct arylation of some heteroaromatics [11]. The
ruthenium-catalysed direct arylation of 2-arylpyridines in
carbonates or water has been reported by Fischmeister,
Dixneuf et al. [12].
Waste prevention is a major requirement in current
organic synthesis. One of the most promising approaches
to reduce the formation of wastes is solvent-free reactions
or highly concentrated reaction media [13,14]. Such
conditions make syntheses easier due to the reduction
in reactor size and to simpler work-up, as there is less
solvent to eliminate at the end of the reaction. Therefore,
the use of such conditions for Pd-catalysed direct
arylations would be environmentally attractive for the
preparation of arylated heteroarenes.
To our knowledge, the influence of the reaction
concentration using various solvents for the palladium-
catalysed direct arylation of heteroaromatics has not yet
been studied. Herein, we wish to report on the palladium-
catalysed direct arylations of a range of heteroaromatic
derivatives with an aryl bromide, using a set of solvents
under various reaction concentrations.
2. Results and discussion
For this study, six solvents were employed. DMA and
DMF, which are classified as ‘‘undesirable’’ solvents for
industrial application, NMP, which is ‘‘usable’’, and also