C.S. Challa, N.K. Katari, V. Nallanchakravarthula et al.
Journal of Molecular Structure 1240 (2021) 130541
Table 1
Effect of reaction conditions on the MCR of 1a, 2a, 3 and 4a.
the view point of the fact that identification of new drugs is one
of the key solutions to the multifaceted problem of drug resistance
[
11]. Notably, drug resistance often causes a major hurdle resulting
in failure of chemotherapy based approaches on several occasions.
Due to our interest in bioactive nicotinonitriles [12] herein we re-
port the synthesis, in vitro and in silico evaluation of a series of
compounds based on the template B (Fig. 1) derived from A. We
have chosen SIRT1 as the pharmacological target for our study be-
cause (i) being considered as important targets for cancer thera-
peutics sirtuins (class III NAD-dependent deacetylases) are shown
to up-regulated in various types of cancer [13] whereas (ii) inhibi-
tion of sirtuins allows re-expression of silenced tumor suppressor
genes, leading to the decreased growth of cancer cells. Moreover,
the rational for choosing SIRT1 as a potential pharmacological tar-
get for the nicotinonitrile derivatives based on B stem from the fact
that the structurally similar nicotinamide C (Fig. 1) is one of the
earliest inhibitors of sirtuins including SIRT1 [14]. While the tem-
plate B, as shown in Fig. 1, has three centers (e.g. C-4, C-5 and C-6)
for the introduction of diversity into the central pyridine ring, we
initially focused on the modification of C-4 and C-6 substituents.
This is because the nature and type of substituents present at these
positions were reported to play key roles in biological activities.
Hence, we aimed to examine the effect of variation of C-4 and C-6
groups on biological activities of such derivatives and consequently,
we required a quick access to 2-amino-4,6-disubstituted nicotinon-
itrile derivatives based on template B.
Yieldb
Entry
Catalyst
Solvent
T (°C)
1
2
.
.
No
No
100
88c
75c
76c
No
Toluene
Toluene
Toluene
MeCN
MeCN
EtOH
DCE
100
3.
4.
Amberlyst-15
Amberlyst-15
Amberlyst-15
Amberlyst-15
Amberlyst-15
Amberlyst-15
Amberlyst-15
Amberlyst-15
Amberlyst-15
No
45–50
25–30
25–30
25–30
25–30
25–30
25–30
25–30
25–30
25–30
25–30
25–30
84
5
6
7
8
.
.
.
.
93
89d
77
74
9.
THF
61
1
1
1
1
0.
No
60
12e
1.
2.
3.
MeCN
MeCN
MeCN
MeCN
49
27c
39c
No
14
Amberlyst-15
a
Reactions were carried out using acetophenone 1a (1 mmol.),
benzaldehyde 2a (1 mmol), 3 (1 mmol), 4 (1 mmol) and a catalyst
in a solvent (5 mL) under ultrasound irradiation for 10 min in the
presence of air.
b
Isolated yields.
c
The reaction was performed in the absence of ultrasound for
3
h.
d
The reaction was performed for 20 min.
e
2. Results and discussion
The reaction was performed under nitrogen atmosphere.
Due to their importance not only in the area of medicinal /
pharmaceutical chemistry but also as valuable precursors in or-
ganic synthesis a diverse range of methods have been reported
for the synthesis of 2-amino nicotinonitrile derivatives [15]. Among
them the multicomponent reaction (MCR) of aldehydes, ketones,
malononitrile, and ammonium acetate has become the most com-
mon route towards the synthesis of this class of compounds. A
wide range of reaction conditions have been reported for this
MCR of which some selected examples include the use of (i) cat-
alysts such as Yb(PFO)4 [16], MgO [17], graphene oxide [18], sil-
[26–30] due to its non-hazardous nature and easy removal from
the reaction mixture, for example, via simple filtration [31]. We
have observed that the use of Amberlyst-15 not only allowed the
reaction to proceed at room temperature but also reduced the re-
action time though marginally. Thus the ultrasound assisted MCR
of ketones (1), aldehydes (2), malononitrile (3), and ammonium ac-
etate (4) was carried out in the presence of Amberlyst-15 in MeCN
under mild conditions to give the desired product 5 in good yields
(Scheme 1). Notably, the use of Amberlyst-15 for the rapid synthe-
sis of 5 is not known in the literature.
ica nanoparticle [19], Bi(NO3)2•5H O [20] etc., or (ii) ionic liquid
2
e.g. 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluroroborate ([Bmim][BF ])
Initially, the MCR of acetophenone (1a), benzaldehyde (2a),
malononitrile (3), and ammonium acetate (4) was carried out in
the absence of any catalyst and solvent under conventional heat-
ing conditions in the presence of air (entry 1, Table 1). While the
desired product 5a was obtained in good yield however the re-
action required maintaining a high temperature e.g. 100 °C and
longer duration e.g. 3 h. The use of toluene (as a solvent) (entry
2, Table 1) or combination of toluene and Amberlyst-15 (as a cat-
alyst) (entry 3, Table 1) did not change the situation significantly
though the reaction temperature could be decreased drastically in
the latter case. However, the use of ultrasound irradiation using a
laboratory ultrasonic bath SONOREX SUPER RK 510H model pro-
ducing irradiation of 35 kHz not only improved the product yield
but also decreased the reaction temperature as well as time (entry
4, Table 1). Indeed, a further improvement in product yield was
observed when the nonpolar solvent toluene was replaced by the
relatively more polar solvent MeCN (entry 5, Table 1). Encouraged
by this observation we carried out the reaction for a longer time
i.e. 20 min however no significant improvement in product yield
was observed (entry 6, Table 1). The use of more polar solvent such
as EtOH or less polar solvents such as DCE (1,2-dichloroethane) or
THF was examined and found to be less effective under the con-
ditions employed (entries 7–9, Table 1). Indeed, the omission of
solvent but not catalyst was also found to be less effective (entry
10, Table 1). To understand the role of air, the MCR was performed
under nitrogen atmosphere when the desired product was isolated
4
[
21] or (iii) only solvent such as polyethylene glycol (PEG) [22]. The
use of microwave [23,24] and ultrasound irradiation [25] has also
been reported for the faster synthesis of this class of compounds.
Indeed, the ultrasound-assisted synthesis of 2-amino nicotinoni-
trile particularly attracted our attention [25] because the method-
ology was free from the use of any catalyst and organic media.
Moreover, the MCR proceeded at 50 °C in pure water affording
the desired products in good yield (75–97%). All these features en-
couraged us to adopt this sonochemical protocol for the synthesis
of our target compounds based on B. However, in our effort we
encountered with some difficulties like sluggishness of the reac-
tion thereby requirement of either longer reaction time or apply-
ing higher temperature. In some cases, the reaction afforded the
intermediate product rather than the desired compound or did not
proceed at all. The reason for such observation appeared to be par-
tially due to the poor solubility of reactants especially the ace-
tophenones in pure water. Indeed, we noted that generally ace-
tophenones containing a phenolic hydroxyl group were used in
the previous study that perhaps aided their solubility in pure wa-
ter. It was therefore necessary to establish an appropriate reac-
tion condition that could serve our purpose. The previous reports
on successful use of acidic catalysts in the synthesis of 2-amino
nicotinonitriles prompted us to explore the use of Amberlyst-15
for accessing the compounds based on B. As a low-cost and readily
available heterogeneous catalyst Amberlyst-15 gained our attention
2