116
Y.Y. Lee et al. / Catalysis Today 232 (2014) 114–118
%
100
Glycerol conversion
Acrolein selectivity
80
60
40
20
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
Amount of loaded phosphate ( wt %)
Fig. 4. Effect of PO4/Nb2O5 catalysts’ amount of loaded PO4 on glycerol conversion
and acrolein selectivity.
amounts of medium strength acid and strong acid increased. The
amount of strong acid site increased significantly compared with
the catalysts with a 20 wt% or lower loading. In summary, as the
amount of PO4 loaded on Nb2O5 is increased, the amount of acid
site and the acid strength also increase.
Fig. 3. TPD profiles of PO4/Nb2O5 samples with different PO4 loadings. (a) Nb2O5,
(b) 10 wt%, (c) 20 wt% PO4/Nb2O5, (d) 30 wt% PO4/Nb2O5, (e) 40 wt% PO4/Nb2O5 and
(f) 50 wt% PO4/Nb2O5.
3.1.4. Catalytic activity
20 wt% or less of PO4 loading, and a weak NbOPO4 crystal peak was
observed at 30 wt% or higher loading. In addition, at 40 wt% and
50 wt% PO4/Nb2O5 catalysts, orthorhombic NbOPO4 crystal struc-
ture was clearly observed around 2ꢀ = 20.7◦, 24.3◦, 29.1◦, 36.1◦,
46.9◦, and 56.4◦.
Fig. 4 presents the reaction activity of the PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst
according to PO4 loading. In the case of the PO4-loaded catalyst,
acrolein selectivity noticeably increased compared with unloaded
Nb2O5 catalysts. Particularly, in accordance with the increase in
PO4 loading, the glycerol conversion rate and acrolein selectivity
increased. In the case of 50 wt% PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst, the glycerol
conversion rate was 68.1% and the acrolein selectivity was 72%,
showing the highest catalyst activity. Under the same reaction
condition, a 50 wt% PO4/Al2O3 catalyst was prepared using low-
activity Al2O3 for the formation of acrolein, and a dehydration
reaction of glycerol was conducted. As a result, the glycerol conver-
sion rate was 24.8%, and the acrolein selectivity was 41.0%, despite
the high amount of PO4 loading. Based on the results, PO4 did not
directly affect the dehydration reaction of glycerol. In the case of
the PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst, a new active site is considered to be formed
by the reaction between Nb2O5 and PO4 in the process of preparing
catalysts.
lent to the acid strength of about 70% H2SO4. NbOPO4 has higher
acidity than Nb2O5·nH2O (H0 ≤ -8.2), which is equivalent to the
acid strength of about 90% H2SO4 [14,15]. In the process of prepar-
ing the PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst, Nb2O5 combines with PO4, to form a
NbOPO4 crystal (Fig. 2). Since NbOPO4 has very strong acidity, the
activity of glycerol dehydration reaction is considered to be high
compared with the Nb2O5 and PO4/Al2O3 catalysts. In the case of
the PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst, increasing the amount of acid site on the
surface and acid strength with the growing amount of PO4 loaded
on Nb2O5 (Fig. 3) has an effect on the glycerol conversion rate and
acrolein selectivity toward high value.
3.1.3. Acidic properties of catalysts
Changes in the surface acidity of the PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst
according to PO4 loading was measured using the ammo-
nia temperature-programmed desorption (TPD) method (Fig. 3).
According to the TPD graph of Nb2O5 loaded with PO4 (Fig. 3(b)–(f)),
the peak area has increased overall upon loading PO4. In the TPD
curves, the peak area of ammonia desorption is associated with the
amount of the acid site. As shown, the amount of acid site on the sur-
face of the catalyst increased upon loading PO4. In the case of 10 wt%
PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst, the peak area of ammonia desorption was con-
firmed to increase more at the range of 100–400 ◦C compared with
the Nb2O5 catalyst. In the case of the 20 wt% PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst,
the peak was observed at a wide range of temperatures, and in
the cases of 30 wt% and 40 wt% PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst, a large ammo-
nia desorption peak was observed at around 600 ◦C. In the case
of 50 wt% PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst, a very large ammonia desorption
peak was observed in the 300–600 ◦C range, and a weak ammonia
desorption peak was observed at 600 ◦C and above, even though
the overlapped weak peak was not clearly seen. Overall, in accor-
dance with the increase in PO4 loading, the peak area is observed to
increase, and the ammonia desorption peak moves from a low tem-
perature range to a high temperature range. In the TPD curve, the
ammonia desorption temperature is associated with acid strength.
While the type of acid site is not clearly differentiated through
TPD analysis, the approximate acid strength can be calculated by
comparing ammonia desorption temperatures. A weak acid is con-
sidered to be the case in which a peak is observed in the range of
120–300 ◦C, while medium strength acid is considered to be a peak
in the range of 300–500 ◦C, and strong acid at a peak in the range
of 500–650 ◦C [7].
3.2. Regeneration of PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst after reaction
When strong acid catalysts are used in reactions, side reactions
inducing carbon deposition on the surface of catalysts frequently
occur. Carbon deposited on the catalyst surface disturbs the reac-
tion on catalyst active sites and reduces catalyst activity.
Fig. 5 presents TG analysis data for comparing the amount of
carbon deposition of the 50 wt% PO4/Nb2O5 catalyst before and
An Ammonia desorption peak appearing within a wide range
of temperatures is usually observed in the case of PO4 loading
of 20 wt% or lower. In the case of 30 wt% or higher loading, the