Organic Letters
Letter
Meanwhile, we also made efforts to verify the feasibility of
this transformation with diverse internal alkynes (Scheme 4).
Scheme 5. Transition States of C−H Activation and Alkyne
Insertion
, ,
a b c
Scheme 4. Scope of Alkynes
dramatically decreases the energy barrier of the O-directed
−
1
pathway by 4.0 kcal·mol . In the alkyne insertion step, the
silver carbonate dimer exhibits an analogous role in stabilizing
the transition states for the catalytic system. According to the
hard−soft acid−base theory, the soft acidic silver ion prefers
the soft basic nitrogen atom to the oxygen atom, reducing the
energy barrier of the alkyne insertion more remarkably. On the
contrary, the N-directed pathway proceeds with a less-
a
Reaction conditions: 1a or 1b (0.1 mmol), 2 (0.15 mmol),
Cp*RhCl2]2 (5.0 mol %), L11 (20 mol %), and Ag CO (1.0
−1
favorable activation free energy, which is 0.9 kcal·mol higher
[
2
3
than the corresponding O-directed pathway in the presence of
equiv) in CH CN (1.0 mL) at 60 °C in oil bath for 24 h under air.
3
−1
b
c
1
silver carbonate dimer (TS−N-Ag-2: 24.1 kcal·mol vs TS−
Isolated yields. The ratio of 3/4 was based on a H NMR analysis.
−
1
O-Ag-1: 23.2 kcal·mol ). This indicated that the O-cyclization
product 3e would be obtained as the major product, which is
consistent with the observed moderate chemoselectivity (8:1).
In addition, when pyridone L11 was added, the energy
barrier of the C−H activation in the O-directed pathway was
The O-cyclization products (3p−3t) could be obtained with
good to excellent yields (70−97%) and high selectivity
(
>20:1). Notably, the oxidative annulation of unsymmetrical
−
1
1
-phenyl-1-pentyne with 1b worked well to obtain the
further lowered by 0.9 kcal·mol . Accordingly, the overall
activation free energy of the O-directed pathway is 1.8 kcal·
regioisomeric mixture of 3u and 3u′ in 88% and 8% yield,
respectively. Propargyl alcohol 2v was tested as well and
provided a 6:1 mixture of isomers.
To understand the chemoselectivity of this reaction, we
performed a series of density functional theory (DFT)
calculations using diphenylacetylene (2a) and amide 1e as
the substrates in the catalytic system. The calculations have
shown that the reaction proceeded through a C−H activation,
alkyne insertion, and metallallylcarbenoid annulation. We
found that the silver salt can act as a Lewis acid to coordinate
with the deprotonated amide moiety in intermediates and
transition states. Different from previous reports on silver
additives serving as either a halide scavenger or a terminal
oxidant for the regeneration of catalytic centers in C−H
transformation, silver carbonate also acts as a Brønsted base
and a Lewis acid to assist the ligands to control the selectivity
of the products in the catalytic system in our work. The silver
carbonate dimer was used as a computational model to
−
1
mol lower than that of the N-directed pathway (TS−N-Ag-
−
1
−1
2: 24.1 kcal·mol vs TS−O-Ag-Py-1: 22.3 kcal·mol ), in
good agreement with the enhanced chemoselectivity of this
reaction (17:1).
The kinetic isotope experiments were conducted with 1e
13
and 1e-d under standard reaction conditions. Ambiguous
5
kinetic isotope effect (KIE) values were obtained (parallel
experiment: kH/kD = 1.26; intermolecular: k /kD = 1.57),
H
indicating that the C−H activation step has a slightly higher
barrier than the next steps. According to our calculations, the
C−H activation step (via TS−O−Ag-Py-1) is only 1.1 kcal
−
1
mol higher than the alkyne insertion (via TS−O-Ag-2) in
the O-directed pathway, which is consistent with isotope
experiments.
On the basis of the experimental results and DFT
calculations, a proposed catalytic cycle is presented in Scheme
6. The catalytic cycle is initiated by the coordination of amide
1e to the activated Rh(III) species, which is dissociated from
the rhodium dimer precatalyst, leading to Rh-amidate
intermediate A. Subsequently, the cyclic rhodium complex
Int-O-3 was furnished through the C−H activation transition
state TS−O-Ag-Py-1 in the presence of silver carbonate dimer.
1
4
The free energies of C−H activation and alkyne insertion
transition states are illustrated in Scheme 5. In the C−H
activation step, coordination of silver carbonate dimer
C
Org. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX