5
524
I. Rivera et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 54 (2013) 5523–5526
Table 1
Results and discussion
Hydrolytic activities of CPL preparations and ratio of lipase versus protease and
esterase activities
Hydrolytic activities of C. papaya crude and partially purified la-
tex (CPLtx, CPL-p, and CPL-e) were evaluated and their perfor-
mance on the kinetic resolution of (R,S)-2-bromophenylacetic
Hydrolytic activity
Biocatalyst
CPL-p
CPLtx
CPL-e
1
2a
acid octyl esters with optimized conditions was compared.
a
Protease
353 ± 2 U/g
1137 ± 37 U/g
593 ± 1 U/g
1.7
7 ± 0.003 U/g
1248 ± 68 U/g
753 ± 0.0 U/g
108
3 ± 0.001 U/g
486 ± 3 U/g
921 ± 32 U/g
307
b
Esterase
c
Hydrolytic activity of CPL preparations
Lipase
Lipase/protease
Lipase/esterase
0.5
0.6
1.9
First, in order to characterize the enzymatic preparations, prote-
ase, esterase, and lipase activities were evaluated with specific
substrates. Table 1 shows the ratio of these hydrolytic activities.
As expected, a high decrease in proteolytic activity was
achieved during the preparation of CPL-p (98%) and only 0.9% pro-
tease activity remained in CPL-e. In this later, lipase is the predom-
inant activity after removal of 43% esterase activity.
Mean and standard deviation of two independent experiments are presented.
a
Measured by casein hydrolysis, 1 U = 1 equiv tyrosine liberated.
Measured by tributyrin hydrolysis, 1 U = 1
Measured by triolein hydrolysis, 1 U = 1
b
lmol acid liberated/min.
c
lmol acid liberated/min.
Table 2
Effect of pH on the racemic resolution of (R,S)-2-bromophenylacetic acid
In previous works dealing with enantioresolution using C. pa-
paya preparations, only CPLtx and CPL-p were tested. Here we
decided to compare each partially purified fraction, including
CPL-e, to discriminate which of protease, lipase, or esterase activity
is responsible for the observed enantioselectivity.
octyl ester catalyzed by CPLtx
pH
Initial reaction rate for the
E
(r
a
S enantiomer, r
S
S R
/r )
À1
À1
(lmol h g enzyme
)
7
8
8.5
9.0
.0
.0
1.45 ± 0.04
2.02 ± 0.00
2.4 ± 0.10
2.3 ± 0.10
30
168
>200
>200
Kinetic resolution of (R,S)-2-bromophenylacetic acid octyl ester
using CPLtx
5
0 mM Substrate in decane, solvent:buffer 1:1, 50 mg/mL of biocatalyst,
CPLtx’s ability to discriminate between enantiomers in the race-
mic mixture of (R,S)-2-bromophenylacetic acid octyl esters was
evaluated in a biphasic medium (water:decane 1:1). Different reac-
tion parameters were evaluated in order to determine their effects
over activity and enantioselectivity.
25 °C
a
Mean and standard deviation of two independent experiments are
presented.
hydrophobicity was thus performed. The highest initial rate was
obtained using decane, the most hydrophobic solvent tested, prob-
ably due to a good emulsification process where the interface
water/solvent is favorable to lipase catalytic performances
(Table 3).
Previous efforts have been carried out in order to relate CPLtx
catalytic performances (reaction rate and enantioselectivity to-
ward 2-mathylalkanoic acid,
2,2,2-trifluoroethyl thioester ) and the properties of the solvent
used. As in our case, no explicit correlation could be found between
solvent properties and initial rates of reaction.
Determination of the optimal substrate concentration is essen-
tial to obtain high initial rate and E-value. As shown in Table 4,
substrate concentration has only a slight influence on the perfor-
mance of CPLtx in the studied range of concentrations. Neverthe-
less, over 100 mM, a slight decrease in reaction rates is observed,
probably due to substrate inhibition.
1
4
Unlike lipases that operate in acidic or neutral media, CPLtx
was previously shown to operate in basic media.15 This constitutes
a major advantage for applications as detergents, dish washing,
and dry cleaning products.16 High activity in alkaline media might
also be an advantage for substrate solubility in synthesis reac-
1
7
tions. Considering the studied reaction, the highest hydrolysis
activity toward the best-recognized enantiomer was indeed ob-
tained at pH 8.5 and 9.0 (Table 2). These results are in agreement
with those obtained by Abdelkafi et al. on triglycerides,1 where
the highest activity was also obtained between pH 8.5 and 9.0.
pH 8.5 was thus retained for the following experiments.
2
0a
20b
propionic acid,
and naproxen
1
3b
5
At pH 8.5, CPLtx exhibited the highest initial rate
À1
À1
(
2.36 ± 0.10 lmol h g enzyme ) of hydrolysis toward the pre-
ferred (S)-enantiomer and a very high enantioselectivity (>200),
which makes this enzyme the most efficient wild-type lipase for
the resolution of this racemic mixture. Indeed, reported enantiose-
lectivity values of wild-type enzymes were much lower than those
obtained using CPLtx (E = 72 for (S)-selective lipase Lip2 from Yarr-
owia lipolytica and E = 53 for (R)-selective lipase from Burkholderia
Kinetic resolution of (R,S)-2-bromophenylacetic acid octyl ester
by CPL-p and CPL-e
4
c,18
cepacia).
It was necessary to improve these microbial lipases’
Finally, the performances of partially purified fractions CPL-p
and CPL-e were analyzed (Table 5). Results showed that the initial
rate of hydrolysis of the preferred (S)-enantiomer increased when
the partially purified fractions of latex were used, due to an enrich-
ment of these fractions in lipolytic activity (see Table 1). Indeed,
the reaction proceeded 2.1 and 2.4-fold faster when CPL-p and
selectivity by site-directed mutagenesis in order to reach high ini-
tial rates and E-values >200.4
b,18
Selection of a proper reaction medium is a key parameter to
optimize any enzymatic reaction, as it can affect both the initial
rate and enzyme selectivity.19 Screening of solvents with different
Scheme 1. Hydrolysis of (R,S)-2-bromophenylacetic acid octyl ester 1 into (R)-2-bromophenylacetic acid octyl ester 2, (S)-2-bromophenylacetic acid 3, and octyl alcohol 4
provided that lipase is S enantioselective).
(