CHEMMEDCHEM
COMMUNICATIONS
DOI: 10.1002/cmdc.201300526
Porphyrin-Based Design of Bioinspired Multitarget
Quadruplex Ligands
Aurꢀlien Laguerre, Nicolas Desbois, Loic Stefan, Philippe Richard, Claude P. Gros,* and
[a]
David Monchaud*
Secondary nucleic acid structures, such as DNA and RNA quad-
ruplexes, are potential targets for cancer therapies. Ligands
that interact with these targets could thus find application as
anticancer agents. Synthetic G-quartets have recently found
numerous applications, including use as bioinspired G-quadru-
plex ligands. Herein, the design, synthesis and preliminary bio-
physical evaluation of a new prototype multitarget G-quadru-
nature of their secondary structures. The therapeutic validity of
this approach is not firmly established yet, but it has been very
elegantly summarized by Stephen Neidle when he recently
stated that “a quadruplex-focused poly-targeting approach may
be especially useful for those genetically highly aberrant solid
cancers where multiple oncogene pathways may be disregulat-
[6]
ed”. Our recent reports on the use of synthetic G-quartets
PNA
[7]
plex ligand, PorphySQ, are reported, where peptidic nucleic
(SQ, also named TASQ) as bioinspired G-quadruplex ligands
PNA
[8–10]
acid guanine ( G) was incorporated in the porphyrin-templat-
have a particular resonance in this context:
our strategy ex-
ed synthetic G-quartet (PorphySQ). Using fluorescence reso-
nance energy transfer (FRET)-melting experiments, PorphySQ
ploits the nature-inspired self-association of G-quartets that is
responsible for the elevated G-quadruplex stability; thus, SQ
interact with quadruplexes lying atop their accessible G-quar-
tet, making them able to bind to virtually any quadruplex
structure since G-quartets are the major and ubiquitous struc-
tural component of quadruplexes. However, our first proto-
types of bioinspired ligands, namely DOTA-templated synthetic
G-quartet (DOTASQ), where DOTA is 1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclodo-
was shown to possess enhanced quadruplex-interacting prop-
PNA
erties thanks to the presence of four positively charged
G
residues that improve its electrostatic interactions with the
binding site of both DNA and RNA quadruplexes (i.e., their
negatively charged and accessible G-quartets), thereby making
PNA
PorphySQ an interesting prototype of a multitarget ligand.
PNA
[8]
Both the chemical stability and water solubility of PorphySQ
decane-N,N’,N’’,N’’’-tetraacetic acid, and porphyrin-templated
[9]
are improved over the non-PNA derivative (PorphySQ), which
are desirable properties for drug development, and while
improvements remain to be made, this ligand is a promising
lead for the further development of multitarget G-quadruplex
ligands.
synthetic G-quartet (PorphySQ) (Scheme 1), were rather per-
fectible: the former for its overall low quadruplex-affinity, the
latter for its quite limited water-solubility. A way to circumvent
both of these problems concomitantly was recently reported
in the DOTASQ series with the introduction of guanine resi-
dues with amine pendant arms (known as peptidic nucleic
PNA
acid guanine,
G) versus neutral guanines for the parent
PNA
Alternative secondary nucleic acid structures, notably DNA and
series. The resulting compound, named
DOTASQ
[
1]
[10]
RNA quadruplexes, are currently a major thrust of targeted
(Scheme 1), displayed improved water solubility, thanks to
the in situ protonation of its amine side chains, and quadru-
plex affinity, thanks to the strong interaction that takes place
between the wreath of positive charges around the SQ and
that of the phosphate negative charges around the native
G-quartet. Herein, we expand the family of bioinspired G-quad-
ruplex ligands, reporting the design, synthesis and preliminary
[
2]
cancer therapies. The recent and unambiguous demonstra-
[
3]
tions of the existence of G-quadruplex DNA in cells is giving
much impetus to the quest of valuable (i.e., efficient and selec-
[
4]
tive) G-quadruplex ligands. However, this enthusiasm is
somewhat offset by the discovery of more and more quadru-
plex-forming sequences in the human genome (belonging to
[
5]
PNA
the so-called “G4 genome”), making the structure-based ra-
tional design of ligands selective for a given subclass of quad-
biophysical evaluation of PorphySQ.
PNA
The design of both PorphySQ and PorphySQ relies on the
[
4]
ruplexes rather challenging. An alternative approach is to
design compounds that interact with quadruplexes whatever
the sequences they fold from, that is to say, whatever the
use of a porphyrin template to intramolecularly assemble the
SQ; the logic behind using a porphyrin platform was fourfold:
1) to promote the formation of a stable SQ through intramo-
lecular SQ/template p-stacking interactions (porphyrins are
[4,11]
known to be efficient quartet interacting compounds);
[
a] A. Laguerre, Dr. N. Desbois, L. Stefan, Dr. P. Richard, Prof. C. P. Gros,
2
) to uncover a novel way for porphyrins to interact with quad-
Dr. D. Monchaud
[12]
Institut de Chimie Molꢀculaire
Universitꢀ de Bourgogne (ICMUB)
CNRS UMR6302, Dijon (France)
E-mail: claude.gros@u-bourgogne.fr
ruplexes (they are indeed known to bind to quadruplexes
[13]
according numerous modes, including quartet
and loop
[14]
[15]
stacking, along with intercalation within or between quad-
[16]
ruplex units and also a more unusual disruptive mode in
[17]
which porphyrins unfold quadruplexes);
3) to exploit this
Supporting information for this article is available on the WWW under
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/cmdc.201300526.
quite unique SQ-mediated quadruplex interaction to make
ꢁ
2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ChemMedChem 0000, 00, 1 – 5
&
1
&
ÞÞ
These are not the final page numbers!