12
J. Ryu et al. / Catalysis Communications 24 (2012) 11–15
control experiment was conducted by adding several promoters or
inhibitors to the reaction mixture containing an imidazolium-based
chloride ionic liquid. From these results, the reaction network was de-
scribed on the fructose dehydration and a discussion was formulated
for the roles of the cation and anion of 1,3-dialkylimidzolium halide.
3. Results and discussion
3.1. Catalytic activity of imidazolium-based ionic liquids
First of all, the catalytic activity of C4mimCl was compared with
those of Nafion NR50, CH3COOH and CaCl2 on the dehydration of
fructose into HMF (Table 1). Among the catalysts, Nafion NR50
showed the highest catalytic performance, where the HMF yield
approached ca. 80% at the reaction time of 5 h. The catalyst,
C4mimCl, also converted fructose into HMF at the considerable yield
of 56%. However, acetic acid was believed to have a negligible activity,
because the HMF yield was very similar to that obtained in the blank
test. On the other hand, it should be noted that the activity of CaCl2
was slightly lower than that of C4mimCl, but higher about two-fold
than that of acetic acid. This suggests that the chloride ion acts as
the catalyst for the conversion of fructose into HMF, which is in
agreement with the results of Binder and Raines [16]. From the
above results, it was assumed that both C4mim+ and Cl− may be
responsible for the fructose-to-HMF conversion.
2. Experimental
2.1. Materials
Fructose (Sigma, ≥99%), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO, Junsei,
≥99.89%, water max. 0.2%), Nafion NR50 (Wako), acetic acid (Yakuri,
99.7%), CaCl2 (Junsei, ≥95.0%), and Ca(CH3COO)2·xH2O (Aldrich,
99%) were used without purification.
1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride (C4mimCl, >98%),
1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium bromide (C4mimBr, >98%), 1-butyl-
3-methylimidazolium methylsulfate (C4mimCH3SO4, >99%),
1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate (C4mimOAc, >99%), 1-hexyl-
3-methylimidazolium chloride (C6mimCl, >99%), 1-hexyl-2,3-
dimethylimidazolium
chloride
(C6mmimCl,
>99%),
and
As a first assessment to address the intrinsic activity of
1-butyl-2,3-dimethylimidazolium chloride (C4mmimCl, >98%), 1-
octyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride (C8mimCl, >98%), and 1-
octyl-2,3-dimethylimidazolium chloride (C8mmimCl, >98%) were
supplied by C-TRI (South Korea). KBr (≥99%), 1-butyl-3-methylimi-
dazolium tetrafluoroborate (C4mimBF4, ≥98.5%), and 1-butyl-3-
methylimidazolium hexafluorophosphate (C4mimPF6, ≥98.5%)
were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich.
imidazolium-based ILs, the effects of alkyl chain length and additional
alkyl group attached to the imidazolium ring were investigated. Since
imidazolium cations with more hydrophobic characters exhibit a
weaker association with the chloride ion [20], they would be
expected to have a positive effective charge of H atom on the C2
position (i.e., C(2)–H) of imidazolim ring and, in turn, become more
active. Thus, 1-R-3-methylimidazolium chloride and 1-R-2,3-
dimethylimidazolium chloride, where R represents butyl (C4), hexyl
(C6) and octyl (C8), were applied for the dehydration of fructose. As
clearly shown in Fig. 1, the activities of all the Cl-containing ionic
liquids were very similar in terms of the fructose conversion as well
as HMF yield whose trends were sigmoid due to an erroneous zero
time caused by a temperature difference between the reaction
mixture and oil bath. Therefore, the length of the alkyl chain and
the additional alkyl group in imidazolium-based ionic liquids did
not afford any noticeable improvement in the fructose dehydration.
This is related with the pKa values of alkylimidazolium chloride
ionic liquids in DMSO, which will be explained later.
Next, the anion could be supposed to alter the ability of imidazo-
lium cations acting as an acid catalyst and take parts in the dehydra-
tion reaction as a neucleophile. The activities of ionic liquids with
various counter-anions associated with the C4mim cation were thus
investigated in order to rationalize the above supposition. Fig. 2 de-
picts the fructose conversion, HMF yield in a unit of % and mol/mol
whose latter is equal to the amount of HMF produced per that of
ionic liquid (C4mimCl, C4mimBr, C4mimBF4, C4mimPF6, C4mimCH3-
SO4 or C4mimOAc) added to the reaction mixture as a function of
the reaction time. As a result, the anion significantly affected the
catalytic activity of C4mim-based ionic liquids. In comparison with
C4mimCl (HMF productivity=3.1 mol/mol·h at 2 h), C4mimBr in
2.2. Activity test
Prior to the reaction, all ionic liquids were pretreated under vacu-
um at 105 °C for 24 h. In a typical experiment, a pre-dried ionic liquid
was added to the fructose solution in DMSO (2 mL), where the fruc-
tose concentration was 2.5 wt.%. The reaction was initiated by im-
mersing the glass reactor of 10 mL in oil bath pre-heated at 80 °C
(t=0). It took less than 10 min to reach the reaction temperature.
In order for the temperature of whole system to remain constant,
the thermo oil and the reactant solution were stirred using magnetic
bars in the oil bath and glass reactors, respectively. Furthermore,
since the experiments were repeated more than three times for
reproducibility, the average of these data was presented in this
work. The reaction temperature of 80 °C was selected, because
DMSO acts as the catalyst for the dehydration of fructose to
5-hydroxymethylfurfural at 150 °C through formation of a key inter-
mediate, (4R, 5R)-4-hydroxy-5-hydroxymethyl-4,5-dihydrofuran-2-
carbaldehyde [19]. In the preliminary blank test with fructose and
DMSO, only 13% of HMF yield was observed at 80 °C for 3 h.
In several control experiments for confirming the effect of ILs' an-
ions, Ca(CH3COO)2, KBr, CH3COOH or Nafion NR50, whose amount
was calculated and weighed beforehand, was added into the reaction
mixture at the reaction time of 1 h.
After termination of the reaction, the product solution was
quenched in ice water, filtered and finally analyzed by a Perkin
Elmer HPLC equipped with RI detector and Bio-Rad HPX-87 C column
with 0.6 mL/min of distilled water at 80 °C. Due to the formation of a
few byproducts, the quantitative amounts of fructose and HMF (mol)
were measured for quantification. Because 1 mole fructose is con-
verted into 1 mole HMF, the maximum amount of HMF generated is
equal to the amount of initial fructose. Thus, the conversion of
fructose and HMF yield were calculated as follows:
Table 1
Catalytic activities of C4mimCl, Nafion NR50, CH3COOH and CaCl2 for the dehydration
of fructose.a
Reaction
time (h)
Fructose
conversion (%)
HMF yield
(%)
HMF/catalyst
(mol/mol)
C4mimCl
Nafion NR50
CH3COOH
CaCl2
2
5
2
5
2
5
2
5
70
97
76
95
53
74
57
95
31
56
57
79
6.6
29
13
55
6.3
11
10
14
1.3
5.7
2.7
11
FructoseconsumedðmolÞ
Fructose conversionð%Þ ¼
HMF yieldð%Þ ¼
ꢀ 100
Initial f ructoseðmolÞ
HMF producedðmolÞ
a
Reaction condition: fructose (50 mg), catalyst/fructose (0.05 mol/mol;), DMSO
(2 mL), 353 K. In the case of Nafion NR50 having the ion exchange capacity of
0.8 meq/g, the weight of catalyst added was 20 mg.
ꢀ 100
Initial f ructoseðmolÞ