Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
Table 1: Optimization of the reaction parameters.[a]
arene partner 2 using SCB 1a (R = Me) and 1b (R = Cl). The
reaction between 2-chlorothiophene (2a) and 1a gave
dibenzosilole 3aa in 60% yield and 86% ee, while the
reaction between 2a and 1b afforded the desired product 3ba
in 63% yield and 93% ee. The silylation of 3-chlorothiophene
(2b) took place exclusively at the 5-position but not at the
competing 2-position, and the corresponding products 3ab
and 3bb were obtained in 64% and 78% yields, with 91% and
88% ee, respectively. The more electron-rich 2-methylthio-
phene 2c was also compatible with the reaction, producing
only one constitutional product 3ac in 65% yield. In this case,
the enantioselectivity was lower (78% ee). The reactions
involving 3-methylthiophene 2d were also very regioselective,
but the enantioselectivities varied significantly: 77% ee was
observed for 3ad and 92% ee was obtained for 3bd.
The less reactive benzene (1e) and 3, 5-difluorobenzene
(1 f) were then employed. Owing to the lower reactivity, they
were used as the solvent for the reaction (see footnote d). The
reaction between benzene with SCB 1a and 1b successfully
afford the desired products 3ae and 3be in a moderate yield
(54%). The enantioselectivities were lower, however, with
65% ee for 3ae and 68% ee for 3be. The absolute
configuration of 3ae was unambiguously determined to be S
by single-crystal X-ray spectroscopy.[27] 3,5-Difluorobenzene
1 f was slightly more reactive, and the reaction gave the
corresponding product 3af in a higher yield (63%) than that
of 3ae with similar enantioselectivity (67% ee).
A number of SCBs bearing different substituents on
ring B were then tested using 2-chlorothiophene 2a as the
arene partner. SCB 1c with an electron-withdrawing para-F
substituent reacted smoothly with 2a to give the product 3ca
in a good yield (70%) with a high enantioselectivity (91% ee).
The electron-donating para-methoxyl group in SCB 1d did
not show an adverse effect, furnishing the product 3da in
a 67% yield with 93% ee. SCBs 1e, 1 f, and 1g bearing meta-
substituents were also capable substrates. The reaction of
SCB 1e afforded the product 3ea in 61% yield and 88% ee,
while SCB 1 f gave the product 3 fa in an excellent enantio-
selectivity (90% ee). To test the limit of the reaction, SCB 1g
was reacted with the least active benzene 2e. The desired
product 3ge was obtained in a 69% yield and a good
enantioselectivity (80% ee). This method was successfully
extended to the synthesis of bis-silole 3ha, which was
obtained in a 54% combined yield (3ha : racemate = 11:1
by HPLC, for details see page 29 in the Supporting Informa-
tion) with 92% ee. When ring B of the substrate was changed
into a ferrocene unit, the reaction showed a very high
efficiency (88% yield). The desired product 3ie was isolated
as a single diastereomer in 91% ee.
Entry
Ligand
Yield [%][b]
ee [%][c]
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
–
–
43
<10
21
28
<10
19
25
35
<10
28
–
À64
À66
60
(S)-DTBM-BINAP
(S)-MeO-Biphep
(R)-DTBM-MeO-Biphep
(S)-TMS-MeO-Biphep
(R)-Segphos
(R)-DM-Segphos
(R)-DTBM-Segphos
(R)-TMS-Segphos
(S)-DTBM-C1-Tunephos
(R)-TMS-Segphos
(R)-TMS-Segphos
(R)-TMS-Segphos
(R)-TMS-Segphos
(S)-TMS-Segphos
À86
22
38
72
86
9
10
11[d]
12[e]
13[e,f]
14[f]
15[g]
À66
86
46, 44[h]
35
60
76
86, 85[h]
86
86
73
[a] Conditions: 1a (0.1 mmol), 2a (0.2 mmol) in p-xylene (1 mL) unless
otherwise noted, 408C for 24 hrs. [b] Isolated yield. [c] Determined by
HPLC. [d] In 1,4-dioxane. [e] In DCE. [f] [Rh(cod)OH] as the catalyst.
[g] Triethylsilane (10 mol%) was added. [h] 3 mmol scale.
uct 3aa was observed in 43% yield with excellent regiose-
lectivity and moderate enantioselectivity (64% ee, entry 2).
MeO-Biphep-type ligands, which possess narrower bite
angles compared with BINAP, were screened (entries 3–5).
Among this type of ligand, the reactivity improved as the
stereohindrance increased, with yields ranging from < 10% to
28%. The (S)-TMS-MeO-Biphep gave a high enantioselec-
tivity (À86% ee). Encouraged by these results, Segphos that
have even narrower bite angles were then examined
(entries 6–9). A similar correlation between the reactivity
and the ligand steric hindrance was again noted. With the (R)-
TMS-Segphos ligand, 86% ee was obtained, albeit with
a lower 35% yield (entry 9).[26] Further increasing the stereo-
hindrance by using (S)-DTBM-C1-Tunephos resulted in
a further decreased yield of < 10% (entry 10).
We then focused on optimizing the reaction using the (R)-
TMS-Segphos ligand. The solvent had a significant effect on
the yield, but not on the enantioselectivity. For example, the
reaction gave the same 86% ee in 1,4-dioxane and in
dichloroethane (DCE), but the yields were much higher in
DCE (entry 11 versus 12). When the reaction was carried out
on 3 mmol scale, product 3aa could also be obtained in
a comparable 44% yield and 85% ee. When [Rh(cod)OH]
was used as the catalyst instead of [Rh(cod)Cl], a 35% yield
was obtained for reaction in DCE (entry 13). Satisfyingly, the
yield was improved to 60% with p-xylene as the solvent
(entry 14). Disiloxane (see Scheme 2) and biphenyl side
products accounted for the mass balance. The disiloxane
can be effectively suppressed by adding triethylsilane at the
cost of the enantioselectivity (entry 15 and Supporting
Information).
The possible pathways of the current reaction are shown
in Scheme 2, which involve different sequences of bond
formation. In pathway a, the well-documented intermolecular
dehydrogenative silylation[22] between the arene and the Si H
À
À
happens first, followed by asymmetric intramolecular C H
silylation of SCB. At face value, the latter step is a close
analogue of the racemic reaction[25b] we reported recently (see
below). Pathway b entails an intramolecular dehydrogenative
silylation, which is also well established.[13] However, the
The substrate scope was demonstrated using the opti-
mized reaction conditions. We first examined the (hetero)-
À
intermolecular C H silylation of SCB is not known to date.
2
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2016, 55, 1 – 6
These are not the final page numbers!