ARTICLE RESEARCH
generically, the dehydro-Diels–Alder (DDA) reaction15. In the light of
the generality of the results we present here, we suggest that the trans-
formation in Fig. 1d would be better named the tetradehydro-Diels–
Alder (TDDA) reaction.
The most highly oxidized Diels–Alder variant (Fig. 1e) is the cyclo-
addition between a 1,3-diyne like 12 and an alkyne diynophile like 7,
which generates o-benzyne (compare 19, 1 and 1*). This hexadehydro-
Diels–Alder (HDDA) reaction is the subject of this Article. Given the
efficiency, ease of precursor access, versatility and mild reaction condi-
tions revealed by the examples we present here, it is remarkable that this
reaction has remained essentially unexploited16–19. It is interesting to
speculate that this may be due in part to the fact that the most common
depiction of benzyne—the resonance contributor 1 (Fig. 1e)—obscures
its potential construction via a [412] cycloaddition reaction. It is the
a
TBSO
O
R2
MnO2, CH2Cl2
Room temperature
R1
OTBS
O
5 h, 53%
O
TBS
R1, R2
t
SiMe2 Bu
15
H,OH
=O
13
14
TBSO
O
TBSO
O
TBSO
O
´
alternative, but rarely encountered, Kekule depiction (19) that reveals
the opportunity for assembly via an HDDA process.
We report below the broad scope of a strategy that combines the
versatile and efficient generation of benzynes via the HDDA reaction
with various trapping reactions to yield structurally complex ben-
zenoid products. Each substrate is a readily accessible conjugated
diyne containing a remote alkynyl diynophile. These cycloisomerize
in (a highly exergonic) [412] fashion to produce the reactive aryne
intermediate. The examples demonstrate that the tandem benzyne
forming/trapping sequence can be designed to proceed with excellent
efficiency.
O
O
O
SiMe2
tBu
SiMe2
tBu
SiMe2
tBu
16′
16
17
b
H
CHO
CHO
19
TBSO
Br
The HDDA reaction revealed
Pd(0) [Sonogashira]
In the course of an otherwise unrelated study, we attempted to prepare
the ketotetrayne 14 by oxidation of the precursor alcohol 13 with
manganese dioxide (Fig. 2a). To our surprise, the major product from
this experiment, formed in about 5 hours, was the (hexasubstituted)
benzene derivative 15 (53% yield after purification). We quickly pos-
tulated that the benzyne intermediate 169/16 was being both readily
formed and efficiently trapped by the nucleophilic oxygen atom in the
fortuitously poised b-siloxyethyl group. Migration of the silyl group
from O to C within zwitterion 17, a retro-Brook rearrangement,
accounts for formation of 15. This constitutes an unprecedented
mode of benzyne trapping. Additionally, the process is attended by
a substantial increase in structural complexity. The potential power of
this transformation was immediately apparent.
We surmised that the modest yield observed in this reaction of
tetrayne 14 reflected the fact that two competitive modes of [412]
cyclization are possible. We were also keen to learn the feasibility of
cyclizationofanalogoustriynes. We thereforedesignedandsynthesized
a substrate—the ketotriyne 21 (Fig. 2b)—that could only undergo a
HDDA reaction with a single regiochemical outcome. Our efforts were
rewarded by its smooth transformation at room temperature to the
hexasubstituted, tetracyclic indenone derivative 22 in 93% yield after
chromatographic purification.
TBSO
18
20
(1) Li
TMS; (2) MnO2, 0 °C
CDCl3
26 °C
O
TMS
TBS
O
TMS
t
1/2 = 7 h
O
46 h, 93%
TBSO
21
22
Figure 2
|
Mechanistic rationale, substrate synthesis and mild conditions
for our initial two HDDA reactions. a, Serendipitous observation of the
HDDA reaction: cyclization of ketone 14 (see blue dashed lines) to putative
benzyne (red) intermediate 16/169 (via formation of the bonds indicated by the
black dashed line in each) and subsequent trapping by the pendant silyl ether
gave a hexasubstituted benzenoid (blue), the indenone 15. b, Synthesis of
21 (via convergentcoupling of 18 with19, addition of an ethynyl unit to 20, and
oxidation) and its facile, high-yielding conversion to the tetracyclic benzenoid
(blue) 22. The adjacent atoms denoted by the triangle and dot in substrate
21 map onto those of the product 22. The half-life (t1/2) for conversion of 21 to
22 was measured by in situ NMR analysis (Supplementary Fig. 1). TBS,
t-butyldimethylsilyl.
Intramolecular trapping
As the examples presented in Table 1 clearly show, the HDDA-
initiated cascade has considerable scope with respect to both the cyclizes more slowly than its N-phenyl amide analogue (entry 5),
cycloisomerization and the intramolecular trapping events. Each sub- consistent with the lower concentration of the s-cis conformation
strate is readily accessible by a convergent coupling strategy (compare required for ring closure; our observations are consistent with the
Fig. 2b). All yields of purified products were $75%, and (with the absence of radical character in both the cycloaddition and trapping
exception of entry 8) all reactions occurred between temperatures of phases of the process (for example, reactions performed in chloroform
20 and 120 uC. Highlights include: the presence of an electron with- solvent, an excellent hydrogen atom donor, have shown no evidence of
drawing substituent on the diynophile enhances substrate reactivity hydrogen atom transfer (entries 4 and 9)); the new silyl ether trapping
(compare conditions for 21 to 22 (Fig. 2b) with entry 1); the activating reaction has considerable generality (entries 1–3, 5, 6 and 8 and Fig. 2);
carbonyl group can be a distal (carboalkoxy) rather than a tethering other efficient internal benzyne traps include tethered alcohols (entries
substituent (entries 2 and 3); many classical methods of aryne gen- 4 and 7), aryl rings ([412] cycloaddition in entry 9), or alkenes (ene
eration are not compatible with electron-withdrawing groups in the reaction in entry 10); seven-membered ring formation isfeasible (entry
substrate20; carbonyl activation is not a necessity (entries 1, 4 and 7); 8), and the robust nature of the substrate and product at the high
products having nitrogen-containing heterocycles annulated to the temperature required for this slower cyclization are noteworthy; and
new arene ring can be prepared (entries 3–5); an ester tether (entry 6) finally the silyl substituents in many of the products provide handles
1 1 O C T O B E R 2 0 1 2
| V O L 4 9 0 | N A T U R E | 2 0 9
Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
©2012