1230
G. Roman / Tetrahedron Letters 55 (2014) 1229–1233
have different reactive sites capable of reacting with an aminome-
thylating agent, the direction of the Mannich reaction can be ratio-
nalized in terms of the relative reactivity of the reactive sites. Also,
the aminomethylation may occur at a specific reactive site accord-
ing to the particular reaction conditions that are employed. In a
classical example, hydroxyaryl methyl ketones can be aminome-
ring para to the phenolic hydroxyl to afford 1-[1-hydroxy-4-(mor-
pholin-4-ylmethyl)-2-naphthalenyl]ethanone (2a), and not at the
methylene
a
to the carbonyl function.16 The use of a two-fold ex-
cess of formaldehyde and morpholine under the same reaction
conditions raised the yield of 2a to 85%; no other by-products
could be detected in the crude reaction mixture by 1H NMR. The
same compound could be obtained, albeit in a lower yield (42%),
when one equivalent of substrate 1 was reacted with one equiva-
lent of morpholine and two equivalents of 37% aq formaldehyde
in benzene at reflux temperature for 3 h.17 The latter synthetic
methodology was subsequently used to obtain a series of phenolic
Mannich bases 2b–j from other secondary aliphatic amines. It
should be noted that diallylamine, N-methylbenzylamine and N-
ethylbenzylamine did not react with substrate 1 under these
conditions.
In order to obtain the ketonic Mannich base from 1, the sub-
strate was subjected to aminomethylation at low pH under the
same conditions (1:2:1 molar ratio of substrate 1, paraformalde-
hyde and morpholine hydrochloride, a catalytic amount of concd
HCl, 2-propanol, reflux, 4 h)12 that were successfully used for
hydroxyacetophenones (Scheme 1). As the work-up afforded only
a low yield (12%) of the desired 3-(morpholin-4-yl)-1-(1-hydro-
xy-2-naphthalenyl)-1-propanone hydrochloride (3a),18 the reac-
tion time was increased to 24 h, but the yield was improved only
marginally. In addition, 1-(1-hydroxynaphthalen-2-yl)prop-2-en-
1-one, a by-product formed from ketonic Mannich base 3a through
a deamination process due to prolonged heating, was detected by
1H NMR in the solid isolated after work-up. No trace of the pheno-
lic Mannich base 2a (as a hydrochloride salt) could be identified in
the proton NMR spectrum of crude 3a, and the TLC analysis of the
extract in ethyl acetate of the aqueous solution of crude 3a after
treatment with excess Na2CO3 [Rf 0.23 (EtOAc–hexanes, 1:1 v/v)
for the free base of compound 3a] showed no trace of compound
2a (Rf 0.44, EtOAc–hexanes, 1:1 v/v). Replacement of morpholine
hydrochloride with dimethylamine hydrochloride afforded 3b in
a yield comparable to that of Mannich base 3a. Hence, the rule
according to which alkyl hydroxyaryl ketones can be chemoselec-
thylated either at the carbon atom
a to the carbonyl group or ortho
to the phenolic hydroxyl, but chemoselective aminomethylation
can normally be achieved by using the appropriate reaction condi-
tions.6 Acetylenic ketones, which have been aminomethylated
either
a to the carbonyl group in acidic medium, or at the ethynyl
function in the presence of copper salts, represent another category
of polyfunctional substrates that can undergo the Mannich reac-
tion in a chemoselective manner.7 In addition, N-propargylanilines
have been aminomethylated either on the aromatic ring para to the
amino group or at the propargyl moiety, depending on the reaction
conditions.8 Also, hydroxyindoles generally afford phenolic Man-
nich bases, but when the position ortho to the hydroxyl function
is blocked, aminomethylation occurs at C-3 to give an indole Man-
nich base.9 To the best of our knowledge, the literature on this to-
pic appears to be limited to the types of substrates mentioned
above. In an effort to understand better, and to gain further insight
into the aminomethylation of polyfunctional substrates, the pres-
ent Letter explores the chemoselectivity of the Mannich reaction
for three distinct types of substrates, each of them featuring two
different activating functional groups in their structure.
The first bifunctional substrate examined in terms of chemose-
lectivity under the Mannich reaction conditions belongs to the al-
kyl hydroxyaryl ketones, and features a carbonyl function and a
phenolic hydroxyl as activating groups. Simple alkyl hydroxyaryl
ketones (such as the isomeric hydroxyacetophenones) have been
thoroughly investigated as substrates in aminomethylation reac-
tions, and the formation of ketonic Mannich bases derived from
hydroxyaryl methyl ketones has been shown to be favored by
the use of amine hydrochlorides in the presence of catalytic
amounts of acid,10 whereas the use of free amines normally affords
phenolic Mannich bases.11,12 However, the application of a set of
specific reaction conditions in the Mannich reaction of similar sub-
strates does not always lead to reaction products having similar
structures. For example, the aminomethylation of 2,4-dihydroxy-
acetophenone with morpholine hydrochloride at low pH produces
high yields of the 3-substituted phenolic Mannich base instead of
the expected ketonic Mannich base.13 To further complicate the
course of the Mannich reaction of this type of substrate, the prox-
imity of the acetyl and hydroxyl groups in ortho-hydroxyacetoph-
enones is known to lead to aminomethylated chromanones
obtained through a sequence comprising the Mannich reaction of
the substrate and ring-closure between the aforementioned groups
in the presence of excess paraformaldehyde.14 In contrast to
hydroxyacetophenones, the Mannich reaction of hydroxynapht-
halenylethanones appears to have been less investigated. A survey
of the literature uncovered a paper by Okuda and Matsumoto15
that reports the formation of a series of aminomethylated deriva-
tives of 1-hydroxy-2-naphthalenylethanone (1) at high pH (free
amines as amine reagents), to which they assigned the structure
of the corresponding ketonic Mannich bases. Intrigued by the
apparently abnormal behaviour of substrate 1 in the Mannich reac-
tion, we decided to replicate the conditions used by the Japanese
researchers (Scheme 1). When heated at reflux temperature in
tively aminomethylated either at the carbon atom
a to the car-
bonyl group or ortho/para to the phenolic hydroxyl, depending
on the pH of the medium, applies to 1-hydroxy-2-naphthalenyl-
ethanone (1) as well.
Dissatisfied with the low yields of ketonic Mannich base 3a, we
decided to attempt to improve them and shorten the reaction time
by employing a microwave-assisted variant of the reaction. An at-
tempt to conduct a typical experiment as described previously19
(2 mmol of substrate 1, 2 mmol of paraformaldehyde, 2 mmol of
morpholine hydrochloride in 4 mL of 1,4-dioxane at 180 °C for
500 s) using a CEM Discover reactor resulted in significant charring
of the insoluble part of the reaction mixture (presumably the
amine hydrochloride, which is also known to readily absorb micro-
waves). A second run under milder conditions (90 °C for 500 s) was
accompanied by reduced charring of the insoluble part of the reac-
tion mixture, but the work-up led only to the recovery of substrate
1. Both the extensive charring and the failure to obtain any reac-
tion products may be due to the limited solubility of morpholine
hydrochloride in 1,4-dioxane.
Preformed aminomethylation reagents have become powerful
tools in the Mannich reaction of various types of substrates.20
Iminium salts (Eschenmoser’s salt and the corresponding chloride
salt, in particular) have been mostly employed for the preparation
of ketonic Mannich bases,21 although reports on the aminomethy-
lation of phenols22 as well as indoles23 with these preformed Man-
nich reagents are also available. Even though both activating
groups present in substrate 1 could potentially direct the Mannich
reaction to either reactive site when iminium salts are employed as
aminomethylating reagents, only the hydrochloride of the phenolic
the presence of 37% formaldehyde (500
lL, 5.5 mmol), and mor-
pholine (435 L, 5 mmol) in ethanol (4 mL) for 2 h, substrate 1
l
(5 mmol) gave a yellow solid which, after one recrystallization
from ethanol, melted at 126–127 °C (Osuka and Matsumoto15 re-
ported 124–126 °C for the compound arising from the same reac-
tion). The NMR analysis of the isolated compound showed that
aminomethylation of substrate 1 had occurred on the aromatic