Use of ESI-MS and PCA to distinguish monosaccharides
a similar way to the formation of protonated disaccharides
from monosaccharide proton-bound dimer dehydration
mentioned by Zapfe and Mu.[14] Although [2M+ Na – H2O]+
ions can be easily observed during MS/MS of [2M + Na]+, the
signal intensity was low and the CID procedure mainly
produces sodiated molecules, as was reported by March and
Stadey.[15] In addition, MS/MS spectra of [M + Na]+ ions
showed a slight difference between Gal, Glc and Man as was
reported by Zhu and Sato.[12] Thus [2M + Na]+ and [M + Na]+
ions were not chosen to distinguish monosaccharide isomers.
Formation of non-covalent dimers during ESI of saccharides
has already been observed and was found to be very often a
concentration-related phenomenon.[16,17] To find the proper
concentration of monosaccharide samples, LOD (limit of
detection) tests for the [2M + Na – H2O]+ ions were performed
for all monosaccharide samples by observing the absence of
[2M + Na – H2O]+ ions with a sample concentration increase
in steps of 50 mM starting from 50 mM; the LOD tests showed
that samples with concentration of 350 mM were capable of
forming [2M + Na – H2O]+ ions for all samples on the Finnigan
LCQDECA instrument. To obtain better [2M+ Na – H2O]+ ion
signal intensity, a sample concentration of 400 mM was finally
set in our experiments.
easily recognized from hexoses (Glc, Man and Gal) according to
its relative abundance ratio of ions at m/z 347 to 275
(1.41 ꢂ 0.042 for Glc, 0.68 ꢂ 0.023 for Man and 0.59 ꢂ 0.012 for
Gal). Although the MS/MS spectra for Man and Gal seemed
quite similar to each other at first glance, they maintained
different relative abundance ratios of ions at m/z 275 to 245
(2.47 ꢂ 0.024 for Man and 3.77 ꢂ 0.016 for Gal) and thus could
also be distinguished. As for the three pentoses (Rib, Ara and
Xyl), they could be distinguished from each other by
comparing the relative abundance ratios of ions at m/z 245 to
215 (0.40 ꢂ 1.23 for Ara, 1.09 ꢂ 0.12 for Rib and 6.93 ꢂ 0.034
for Xyl).
Fragmentation mechanism
The [2M + Na – H2O]+ ions are in essence sodium-ionized
disaccharides, so the fragmentation pattern of the MS/MS
spectrum of [2M + Na – H2O]+ ions can be explained as that
of the disaccharides. It is clear that the ions at m/z 347 and
287 were formed due to loss of water of hexoses and pentoses,
respectively, and the other fragment ions may arise from the
precursor ion as shown in Supplementary Fig. 2 (see
Supporting Information).
The mass spectra of hexoses and pentoses are shown in Fig. 1;
in the case of hexoses, the ions [M+ Na]+ (m/z 203), [2M + Na]+
(m/z 383) and [2M + Na – H2O]+ (m/z 365) were observed, while
pentoses showed ions at m/z 173 ([M+ Na]+), m/z 323
([2M + Na]+) and m/z 305 ([2M+ Na – H2O]+), and for desose
they were m/z 187 ([M + Na]+), m/z 351 ([2M + Na]+) and
m/z 333 ([2M + Na – H2O]+). As the only desose, Rha can be
identified directly by its quasi-molecular ion from the MS
mode. To distinguish different hexoses and pentoses, MS/MS
was adopted to investigate the dimer dehydrate ions.
Breakdown curves of the MS/MS ions were generated for the
dimer dehydrate ions of all the monosaccharides (see
Mechanisms of the generation of MS/MS fragment ions
from the precursor [2M + Na – H2O]+ ions of hexoses (except
for Fru) and pentoses have been proposed. Glucose and
arabinose were chosen as examples to demonstrate the
fragmentation pathways for hexoses and pentoses,
respectively. Supplementary Scheme
2 (see Supporting
Information) shows the fragmentation mechanism of glucose. In
the MS/MS spectra, a loss of 60 Da (C2O2H4, HOCH = CHOH)
was observed from [2Glc + Na – H2O] at m/z 365, which
was formed due to the fragmentation from m/z 365 ! 305.
A further fragmentation from m/z 305 ! 275 and m/z
275 ! 245 showed the successively losses of 30 Da (HCHO).
In addition, the fragmentation mechanism of arabinose
can be found in Supplementary Scheme 3 (see Supporting
Information). Similar to glucose, a loss of 60 Da (C2O2H4,
HOCH = CHOH) from the precursor ion [2Ara + Na – H2O]+
at m/z 305 gave the fragment ion at m/z 245, which was further
fragmented and produced the ion at m/z 215 corresponding to a
loss of 30 Da (HCHO). All these results have been confirmed by
HR-ESI-MS/MS obtained from a LTQ Orbitrap LX mass
Supplementary Fig. 1, Supporting Information). With
a
collision energy lower than 25%, the relative abundances of
the product ions of these dimer dehydrate ions were low
compare to that of their precursor ions (base peaks), while the
breakdown curves for all but the precursor ions became flat
when the precursor ions were fragmented with a collision
energy higher than 30%. This means that a better MS/MS
spectra reproducibility could be obtained when the
experiments were carried out with a collision energy higher than
30%, and this is why the product ions of [2M + Na – H2O]+ and
30% normalized collision energy were chosen for differentiation
of monosaccharides.
spectrometer (Supplementary Table
1
(see Supporting
Information) and Table 2), and conform to the results reported
by Hofmeister et al.[18] and Salpin and Tortajada.[17]
The MS/MS spectra generated from [2M + Na – H2O]+ ions
at m/z 365 (hexoses) and 305 (pentoses) presented a series of pro-
duct ions as shown in Fig. 2(a) (for four hexoses) and Fig. 2(b)
(for three pentoses). The hexose isomers and pentose isomers
gave similar product ions with different relative abundant
ratios, respectively. The product ions were detected at m/z
185, 203, 245, 275, 305 and 347 for hexose isomers (except for
Fru), and m/z 173, 215, 245 and 287 for pentose isomers. It
should be noticed that, as a ketose, Fru presented a special
fragmentation pattern; the lack of peaks at m/z 245 and 305
made it different from the other three hexoses. Although
[2M + Na – H2O]+ ions of hexoses (Glc, Man and Gal) and
pentoses (Rib, Ara and Xyl) showed similar fragmentation
patterns, the relative abundances of their product ions showed
the potential to distinguish the saccharide isomers. Glc could be
Principal component analysis
PCA was employed to analyze the MS/MS data obtained
from the [2M + Na – H2O]+ ions of different monosaccharide
isomers (for hexoses they were Glc, Man and Gal, while, for
pentose, they were Rib, Ara and Xyl) with the software
SIMICA-P + (version 11.0, Umetric, Umea, Sweden). Intensi-
ties of the MS/MS ions of [2M + Na – H2O]+ (m/z 185, 245,
275, 305 and 345 for hexose isomers and m/z 173, 215, 245
and 287 for pentose isomers) were chosen as components
for PCA. Good spatial resolution was obtained in the
PCA plot (Fig. 3), which showed clustering of MS/MS data
of identical monosaccharide samples obtained from
different experiments.
Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 2012, 26, 1259–1264
Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/rcm