A1602
Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 149 ͑12͒ A1598-A1603 ͑2002͒
weight ratios between the cathode materials (LiMn2O4 , LiCoO2 ,
and LiNiO2) and carbon-coated Si anode are indicated in the figure.
In these cells, the high coulombic efficiency as in the carbon-coated
Si/Li metal cell could not be obtained and the discharge capacities
͑deintercalation from Si-based anodes͒ were a little lower than 800
mAh/g. This may be due to some limitations in cathode materials.
Moreover, the average working voltages of these cells were ca. 3.5
V ͑carbon-coated Si/LiMn2O4), 3.4 V ͑carbon-coated Si/LiCoO2),
and 3.25 V ͑carbon-coated Si/LiNiO2), respectively. These values
are ca. 0.3 V lower than the working voltages of the corresponding
cells using graphite as anode material.
As demonstrated above, high reversible capacity of 800 mAh/g
can be obtained by the constant capacity charge mode for carbon-
coated Si. Figure 5 shows the cycle life behavior of carbon-coated Si
using the constant voltage charge mode. After being charged to 800
mAh/g and discharged to 1.5 V in the first cycle, the cell was
charged to 100 mV and held at this voltage for 130 min from the
second cycle on. As a result, both the charge and discharge capaci-
ties in the second cycle are low, and from the third to the 10th cycle,
both the charge and discharge capacities grow up until the saturation
value of 980 mAh/g. From the 10th cycle, the capacities fade slowly
with the cycles. Therefore it seems that charge ͑intercalation of
lithium into Si-based electrode͒ mode plays a very important role in
the cyclability of the carbon-coated Si electrode.
The above satisfactory electrochemical performance of carbon-
coated Si was obtained in the EC-based electrolyte of 1 M
LiPF6-EC:DMC ͑1:2 by volume͒. To make carbon-coated Si a ver-
satile anode material for lithium-ion batteries, the compatibility of
carbon-coated Si with PC-based electrolyte was also tested. Figure 6
shows the initial charge/discharge curves of the carbon-coated
Si/LiCoO2 cell in the electrolytes of 1 M LiPF6-EC:DMC ͑1:2 by
volume͒ and 1 M LiPF6-propylene carbonate ͑PC͒. It can be seen
that there is almost no difference in the charge curves for both the
EC and PC-based electrolytes, other than one small shoulder at 3.2
V in the charge curve for 1 M LiPF6-PC electrolyte, which is due to
the mild decomposition of the electrolyte on the surface of carbon-
coated Si. This indicates that a Si-based electrode also is compatible
with PC-based electrolytes.
Figure 8. DSC thermal profiles of carbon-coated Si lithiated to 800 mAh/g
and MCMB 6-28 lithiated to 330 mAh/g.
0 ppm can be observed. The intensities of this signal are very high.
So it seems more likely the peak at 0 ppm originates from the Liϩ
irreversibly bonded with Si-based material. With increasing lithia-
tion extent ͑charge capacities of 500, 1000, and 2000 mAh/g͒, as
shown in Fig. 7b, the intensities of the peaks at 7.3 and 20.2 ppm
increase whereas that at 0 ppm decreases relatively, and becomes a
shoulder of the former peaks. In the 7Li NMR spectra of carbon-
coated Si electrodes fully delithiated from the charged capacities of
500, 1000, and 2000 mAh/g, respectively, as shown in Fig. 7c, the
signal at 0 ppm is always very large, and the signal at 7.3 ppm
becomes a very small shoulder of the peak at 0 ppm in the cases of
charge capacities of 1000 and 2000 mAh/g. The signal at 20.2 ppm
cannot be seen in all the spectra of fully delithiated Si-based elec-
trodes. Therefore, the signal at 0 ppm can be mainly attributed to
Liϩ irreversibly bonded with carbon-coated Si, whereas the signal at
20.2 ppm originates from lithium reversibly alloyed with Si.
To evaluate the thermal stability of carbon-coated Si electrodes,
DSC experiments were carried out on lithiated carbon-coated Si and
mesocarbon microbeads ͑MCMB͒ 6-28. Figure 8 shows the DSC
thermal profiles of carbon-coated Si lithiated to 800 mAh/g and
MCMB 6-28 lithiated to 330 mAh/g. The exothermic peaks lower
than 150°C can be observed for both lithiated Si-based material and
MCMB, which originate from the breakdown of the SEI layer.11,12
These peaks demonstrate close intensities. This implies similar exo-
thermic heat generations. Moreover, the onset temperature of the
exothermic peak corresponding to lithiated carbon-coated Si is a
little higher than that of the lithiated MCMB. In addition, two exo-
thermic peaks appear at temperatures higher than 250°C for each
DSC thermal profile. These peaks may be due to the reaction of
intercalated lithium ͑into Si or C͒ with PVDF binder.12 The exother-
mic heat generation corresponding to the peaks of lithiated carbon-
coated Si higher than 250°C amount to almost three times of that of
lithiated MCMB. This seems in accord with their relative capacities
to accommodate lithium. Thus, carbon-coated Si is a little thermally
safer than the conventional anode material, graphitic carbon, at tem-
peratures lower than 150°C.
To shed more light on the storage states of lithium in Si-based
electrodes, 7Li NMR was applied on the Si-based electrodes with
different charge and discharge capacities as shown in Fig. 7. In the
7Li NMR spectra ͑as shown in Fig. 7a͒ of the carbon-coated Si
electrode being charged ͑intercalation of lithium͒ with 500 mAh/g in
the first cycle, there are mainly three peaks at the chemical shifts of
Ϫ2.7, 4.7, and 17.7 ppm, respectively. On the other hand, in the 7Li
NMR spectra of carbon-coated Si electrode charged with 500 mAh/g
in the fifth cycle ͑after constant capacity charge of 500 mAh/g for 4
cycles͒, two peaks can be observed at the chemical shifts of 7.3 and
20.2 ppm, respectively. If we correct the chemical shift of the peak
7
at Ϫ2.7 to 0 ppm in the former Li NMR spectra, the peaks at 4.7
and 17.7 ppm can be modified to 7.4 and 20.4 ppm, repectively. The
7Li NMR spectra of carbon-coated Si lithiated to 500 mAh/g at
different cycles ͑first and fifth͒ demonstrate almost the same signals
at ca. 7.3 and 20.2 ppm, except the peak at 0 ppm in the spectra at
the first cycle. Moreover, the intensity ratios of the peaks at 7.3 and
20.2 ppm for both spectra are near. From the chemical shifts of the
7
signals in the Li NMR spectra of lithiated Si-based electrodes, the
Conclusion
highly ionic states of lithium stored in the carbon-coated Si can be
clarified. As for the peak at 0 ppm in the first cycle, it may originate
from two sources: ͑1͒ the signal of the residue electrolyte on the
surface of the Si-based electrode; ͑2͒ some response from lithium
inserted into Si based electrodes. However, the signal from the resi-
due electrolyte must be much weaker as compared with the response
from lithium inserted into the electrode since the electrode material
was tested by 7Li NMR after being rinsed with DMC solvent and
So far we have showed the excellent electrochemical perfor-
mance of carbon-coated Si as anode materials for lithium-ion bat-
teries in terms of high reversible capacity over 800 mAh/g, high
coulombic efficiency, good cyclability, satisfactory compatibility
with both the EC and PC-based electrolytes, and better thermal sta-
bility than that of graphite, etc. Carbon-coating in the outer layer
plays a very important role in the improvement of the electrochemi-
cal behavior. It could not only considerably suppress the big decom-
position of electrolytes on the surface of Si-based electrodes, but
also provide integral and continuous electric contact networks
7
dried. In the Li NMR spectra of the carbon-coated Si electrodes in
fully discharged ͑deintercalation of lithium from 500 mAh/g lithi-
ated carbon-coated Si states, as shown in Fig. 7c, only the signal at
Downloaded on 2013-02-24 to IP 137.99.31.134 address. Redistribution subject to ECS license or copyright; see www.esltbd.org