Full Papers
different reaction rates in the dehydration of fructose to HMF.
For Beta(OF)-Cal500, fructose was promptly consumed by its
dehydration reaction to HMF. In contrast, the dehydration rate
for Beta(OF)-Cal700 was slower, resulting in the relatively large
amount of fructose remaining. For Beta(OF)-Cal700, the lower
selectivity to HMF in the dehydration step, as shown in Table 2,
led to the decreased maximum yield of HMF in the conversion
of glucose.
As mentioned above, a large number of Brønsted acid sites
is a key factor for the selective production of HMF from glu-
cose. This prompted us to ask: can we obtain HMF in a high
yield by using a mixture of zeolite Beta with a low B/L ratio
and that with a high B/L ratio? Thus, we performed reaction
using a mixture of Beta(OF)-Cal700 (B/L ratio=1.1) and zeolite
Beta with a high B/L ratio (about 8.5), designated as “Beta-
HBL”. The combination of 0.1 g of Beta(OF)-Cal700 and 0.5 g of
Beta-HBL led to an increase in the selectivity of HMF, accompa-
nied by a decrease in the selectivity of fructose compared with
the single use of Beta(OF)-Cal700 (Table 3, entries 5 and 6).
However, the conversion of glucose was not much changed;
Beta-HBL mainly promoted the dehydration of fructose
(Table 3, entry 7). Clearly, the whole product selectivity is large-
ly governed by Beta(OF)-Cal700. Additionally, the combination
of 0.1 g of Beta(OF)-Cal700 and 0.1 g of Beta(OF)-Cal500
showed 56% selectivity for HMF, indicating that the apparent
selectivity is determined by the individual selectivity
The solvent system is also a key factor for the high yield of
HMF; dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and tetrahydrofuran sup-
pressed the subsequent reactions of HMF into levulinic acid
[
15]
[3a]
and humins. Our previous results and the data in Table S1
in the Supporting Information) clearly demonstrated the ef-
(
fects of the mixed solvents.
The selectivities of fructose and HMF were compared at high
conversions of glucose (80–88%) and the different selectivities
for the Beta(OF) zeolites can be seen in Table 3. Beta(OF)-
of each Beta(OF) component (Table 3, entries 2, 5,
Table 3. Conversion of glucose to HMF by using Beta(OF) and other types of
catalysts.
and 8). This behavior could be ascribed to slow intra-
zeolitic diffusion as a result of a relatively large mo-
lecular dimension of fructose compared with the
pore diameter of zeolite Beta. In fact, Beta(OF) zeo-
lite, which has a large number of Brønsted acid sites
in close proximity to the Lewis acid sites, has an ad-
vantage over mixtures of each type of catalysts.
From an industrial viewpoint, a high concentration
of substrate is feasible. Notably, Beta(OF)-Cal500 still
exhibited high catalytic performance in a concentrat-
ed reaction system; 68% selectivity for HMF was ach-
ieved at 97% conversion of glucose in 10 wt% solu-
tion (Table 3, entry 9).
[a]
Entry
Catalyst
Conv.
Fructose
Select. [%]
HMF
Select. [%]
[
b]
[c]
[d]
[
%]
1
2
3
4
5
Beta(OF)-Cal450
Beta(OF)-Cal500
Beta(OF)-Cal550
Beta(OF)-Cal600
Beta(OF)-Cal700
Beta(OF)-Cal700+ Beta-HBL
Beta-HBL
Beta(OF)-Cal500+ Beta(OF)-Cal700
Beta(OF)-Cal500
Beta(OF)-Cal700-AT
Beta(TEA)-Cal500
Beta-CV
81
86
88
86
80
85
19
96
97
40
81
65
83
4
3
4
12
15
4
3
3
1
2
65
66
67
55
45
55
39
56
68
24
50
43
49
[
e]
6
7
8
9
1
[
[
f]
g]
0
[h]
1
1
1
9
14
1
1
2
3
The Al content of aluminosilicate zeolites synthe-
sized by OSDA-free routes, except for RTH-type zeo-
[
i]
USY
[
16]
lites, is generally uncontrollable and too high for
direct catalytic applications; for example, the Si/Al
ratio for OSDA-free Beta ranges from 4 to 6. Such
high-Al-content zeolites are normally used as solid
[
0
a] Reaction conditions: catalyst, 0.1 g; glucose, 0.67 mmol; water, 4.5 mL; DMSO,
.5 mL; THF, 15 mL; temperature, 1808C; time, 3 h. [b] Conversion of glucose. [c] Se-
lectivity for fructose. [d] Selectivity for HMF. [e] The combination of 0.1 g of Beta(OF)-
Cal700 and 0.5 g of Beta-HBL. The total numbers of Brønsted and Lewis acid sites
were 0.075 and 0.026 mmol, respectively, B/L=2.9. [f] The combination of 0.1 g of
Beta(OF)-Cal500 and 0.1 g of Beta(OF)-Cal700. The total numbers of Brønsted and
acid catalysts after being converted to low-Al-content
À1
[7b,c]
Lewis acid sites were 0.091 and 0.039 mmolg , respectively, B/L=2.3. [g] Reaction
ones by post-synthesis treatments.
Therefore, we
conditions: catalyst, 0.75 g; glucose, 10 mmol; water, 4.5 mL; DMSO, 0.5 mL; THF,
prepared a high-silica Beta(OF) zeolite by treating
1
5 mL; temperature, 1808C; time, 3 h. [h] Reaction time, 5 h. [i] Reaction time, 1 h.
Beta(OF)-Cal700 with 1m HNO at 808C (designated
3
as “Beta(OF)-Cal700-AT”). However, Beta(OF)-Cal700-
AT, with a Si/Al ratio of 52, showed poor catalytic per-
Cal450, -Cal500, and -Cal550, which had a large number of
Brønsted acid sites, showed high selectivities to HMF (65, 66,
and 67%, respectively). On the other hand, Beta(OF)-Cal600
and -Cal700, with a small number of Brønsted acid sites,
showed low selectivities to HMF (55 and 45%) but high selec-
tivities to fructose (12 and 15%). These results verified that
a large number of Brønsted acid sites is an essential factor for
achieving the selective production of HMF. At the same time,
a sufficient number of Lewis acid sites are essential for the
rate-determining isomerization step, as revealed by our previ-
formance (Table 3, entry 10). Beta(OF)-Cal500 showed higher
selectivity for HMF than Beta(TEA)-Cal500 with a Si/Al ratio of
15. Furthermore, it took 5 h for Beta(TEA)-Cal500 to achieve
a conversion over 80% (Table 3, entries 2 and 11). In addition,
a commercially available zeolite with a Si/Al ratio of 13, desig-
nated as Beta-CV, showed poor performance (Table 3,
entry 12). These findings clearly indicate that the removal of Al
atoms from Beta(OF) leads to decreased catalytic activity and
that Beta(OF) can be used as a highly effective acid catalyst
when the high Al composition is kept. Beta(OF)-Cal500 was
also compared with USY zeolite, which can be synthesized
without OSDAs. USY, with a Si/Al ratio of 5.4, showed a faster
reaction rate than all of the Beta(OF) zeolites; however,
[
3a]
ous work. Thus, Beta(OF)-Cal500, which had a large number
of Brønsted acid sites with a sufficient number of Lewis acid
sites, showed the highest yield of HMF.
ChemCatChem 2015, 7, 4180 – 4187
4184
ꢀ 2015 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim