3554
S. P. Muench et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 23 (2013) 3551–3555
A more challenging aspect of the project was to produce a mod-
that is, the A-ring would take the position of the B-ring and vice
versa, by the FLEXX docking program. This altered pose was observed
due to the large substituent on the A-ring causing severe steric
clashes within the binding site which could only be relieved
through the reverse binding mode. However, by allowing for flex-
ibility within the active site, in particular the movement of Phe243
about Cb within the TgENR/NAD+ complex using the Swiss PDB
Viewer the original binding mode was seen.34 Those orientations
that could accommodate the greater steric bulk of our hybrid com-
pounds resulted in a more open binding site such that the A-ring
modification is now exposed to the exterior solvent (Fig. 1C and
D). We have previously seen the movement of Phe243 about the
Cb, in a manner similar to that of the modeling in a TgENR co-crys-
tal structure for a different family of inhibitors (data not shown).
Subsequent docking of the compound series was carried out using
AUTODOCK 4.235 or MACROMODEL version 8.136 and PDB IDs 2O2S20 and
1LX637 available from the RCSB Protein DataBank.
ification on the A-ring of triclosan, which occupies an enclosed
hydrophobic region, resulting in its exposure to the outside solvent
thus allowing for its attachment to a delivery peptide. This is due
to the A-ring of triclosan being buried within the binding site,
whereas the B-ring is at the base of a channel which leads to the
solvent. The tight packing about the A-ring within the ENR enzyme
binding site often makes modifications about this ring difficult as
there are several residues predicted to make steric clashes with
these modified structures, as seen in docking simulations. It is
important to note however that most modeling programs do not
account for protein flexibility within the binding site.33
A solution to this problem was suggested through previous
studies of compound 33 (Fig. 2 (Stec et al., in press)). This com-
pound was predicted to bind in a reverse mode to that of triclosan,
A hybrid triclosan scaffold was then designed which contained
both A and B ring modifications allowing for the compound to be ex-
posed to the solvent on both ends of the molecular scaffold (10).
Modeling studies for this compound with increased bulk on both
the A- and B-rings does not permit the reverse mode binding seen
for the compound 33, but instead adopts the position shown in Fig-
ure 1. Importantly, this compound, despite its bulkier nature,
showed no decrease in MIC50 value but a slight increase in IC50 value
from 29 nM (6) and 19 nM (compound 33) to 137 nM (10). This in-
crease in IC50 to 137 nM is still therapeutically viable and more
importantly, the modifications to both the A and B-ring has resulted
in a compound which is amenable to further structural modifica-
tions to improve both binding and delivery via releasable/non-
releasable trans-peptide linkers. In vitro cytotoxicity tests also
showed no noticeable increase in toxicity based on the assay used.
Growth was measured using a type 1 T. gondii parasite tachyzoite
RH stably transfected with the yellow fluorescent protein (RH-YFP)
gene, with the relative fluorescence intensities of the parasites being
directly correlated with parasite viability and numbers (Fig. 3).
The activity of the 3 compounds (6, 7 and 10) were also tested
against two different strains of P. falciparum (D6 & TM91C235) in a
dose-response growth inhibition assay. Only 6 showed modest
activity against the drug sensitive strain, D6, but no activity against
the drug resistant strain, TM91C235 (Table 1). It is likely that the
non-essential nature of the FASII pathway within the blood stage
of the P. falciparum is responsible for the poor inhibitory effect of
these compounds within our assay.22 Further work will determine
the potency of these inhibitors against the liver stage parasite
which would be important in stopping recrudescence of the Plas-
modium parasite.
These results have shown how the triclosan scaffold can be
modified to result in both the A- and B-rings being exposed to
the exterior solvent without a significant loss in potency or detect-
able increase in toxicity. This is important since it allows for fur-
ther structural modifications to be made which are not
constrained by the size of the binding site. This also allows for
the addition of chemical functionalities which may aid in the deliv-
ery of triclosan into the apicoplast, a significant problem in current
drug design. Moreover, the bradyzoite form of T. gondii is currently
impossible to treat with current therapeutics due to the barriers
put in place by the cyst form of the parasite. Further work will
be carried out to use this scaffold as a basis for modifications by
various linker elements which may aid in drug delivery and target-
ing of a compound whose potency is in the nanomolar range.
Figure 3. Efficacy and absence of toxicity of compounds against T. gondii tachyzo-
ites. (A) Growth of RH-YFP in human Foreskin fibroblasts (HFF), measured as
fluorescence intensity. HFF infected with RH-YFP tachyzoites and fluorescence
intensities were measured after 72 h. Non infected fibroblasts that provided a
baseline control, HFF cells infected with 3200 RH-YFP tachyzoites treated with
pyrimethamine/sulfadiazine (p/s) or 0.1% DMSO serve as positive and negative
controls respectively. (B) Inhibitory effect of the compounds on RH-YFP. HFF cells
were infected with 3200 RH-YFP tachyzoites, compounds at various concentrations
were added 1 h after infection. The fluorescence intensities of the samples as
reflecting numbers of parasites were measured 72 h after addition of compounds.
(C) Effect of the compounds on HFF viability. The viability of host HFF cells was
assessed by Wst-1 staining, after 72 h of incubation of compounds at 10 mM
concentration. Effect of various concentrations of DMSO present in the HFF culture
medium shows varying amounts of toxicity.
Acknowledgments
We thank Dr. Alan Kozikowski for his contributions. The
authors are grateful for the financial support provided by NIAID