D. Hershelman, et al.
ArchivesofBiochemistryandBiophysics674(2019)108082
97:3 for the wild-type enzyme. At pH 7.5, the ratio of 13-HPOD to 9-
HPOD was 63:37 for the F557V mutant compared with 92:8 for the
wild-type. The ratios observed with the wild-type enzyme are in rea-
sonable agreement with previously reported values [20,21]. The results
with the F557V mutant at pH 7.5 were obtained with three different
preparations of this mutant. The results indicate that replacing phe-557
with valine increases the yield of 9-HPOD, but not by a large enough
amount to make it the major product.
To analyze the stereochemistry, 13-HOD and 9-HOD from an ex-
periment with the F557V mutant at pH 7.5 were converted to their
methyl esters, which were purified by normal-phase HPLC and analyzed
by chiral-phase HPLC (Fig. S2). The configuration at C-13 of methyl 13-
HOD was primarily S (S:R = 95:5), as is the case with wild-type SBLO-
It was found that the activity of the F557V,R707L mutant in crude
lysates could be increased to about 10% of wild-type level if the ex-
pression procedure was altered to increase the amount of time the cells
were incubated with ethanol prior to harvesting [47] (see Supplemental
Data). This modified procedure also appeared to increase the stability of
the activity. Analysis of the products formed from linoleic acid by the
crude lysate at pH 7.5 gave the same product ratio (13-HOD/9-
HOD = 89:11) as obtained with our standard expression procedure.
The F557V,R707L mutant expressed by the modified procedure was
purified to yield homogeneous enzyme with a specific activity of 15
units/mg, in contrast to values of 140–180 units/mg that we typically
obtain with wild-type enzyme. Product analyses were carried out by the
same procedures used to obtain the data in Table 1. Three experiments
at pH 7.5 gave an average 13-HOD/9-HOD ratio of 88( 2):12( 2).
The chromatograms also contain two minor unidentified products, each
corresponding to 1–2% of the total (see Fig. S3),. These products were
also observed in the experiments with crude lysates. At pH 9.0, the 13-
HOD/9-HOD ratio was 95:5, and the minor products were not observed.
Comparison of these results with those for the F557V mutant indicates
that replacing arg-707 with leucine shifts the product ratio in favor of
oxygenation at C-13, as expected from the model in Scheme 2.
The 13-HOD and 9-HOD from one of the experiments with the
purified mutant at pH 7.5 were converted to their methyl esters, which
were purified by HPLC. Analysis by chiral-phase HPLC indicated the
methyl 13-HOD was almost entirely S (S/R = 98:2). The methyl 9-HOD
was also predominately S, but the enantioselectivity (S/R = 77:23) was
lower than that obtained with the F557V mutant.
1. The configuration of 9-HOD at C-9 was also primarily
S
(S:R = 87:13). The 9(S) enantiomer is expected if the 9-oxygenated
product results from binding in the opposite orientation from the one
leading to 13-oxygenation, assuming O2 approaches C-9 of the bound
pentadienyl radical through the same channel that is used in oxyge-
nation at C-13.
Kinetics experiments on the oxygenation of linoleic acid by the
F557V mutant were carried out at pH 9.0 using a spectrophotometric
assay that measures the total rate of diene hydroperoxide formation.
The kinetics give a reasonable fit to the Michaelis-Menten equation at
substrate concentrations up to 40 μM with kcat = 76
m = 13 1 μM. Studies in our lab with wild-type SBLO-1 give kcat
values in the range of 230–270 s−1 and Km = 13
1 μM. The lower
4 s−1 and
K
kcat of the F557V mutant suggests that phe-557 may be important for
optimal positioning of linoleic acid for C(11)-H abstraction. The F557V
mutant exhibits substrate inhibition at concentrations above 60 μM.
The data in Table 1 indicate that the ratio of 13-HPOD to 9-HPOD does
not vary appreciably from 15 to 200 μM linoleic acid. These results
indicate that although high concentrations of substrate reduce the rate
of the reaction, they do not substantially affect the product ratio.
Following the proposal of Hornung et al. [29], our working hy-
pothesis was that the smaller size of valine compared with phenylala-
nine is responsible for the change in product ratio observed with the
F557V mutant. This reasoning suggests that the product ratio might be
further shifted towards 9-HPOD by introducing residues at position 557
that are smaller than valine. Contrary to this expectation, the F557A
mutant gave a 13-HPOD/9-HPOD ratio of 88:12 at pH 7.5 and 96:4 at
pH 9. The 13-isomer had an S/R ratio of 98:2. The F557S mutant gave a
ratio of 91:9 at pH 7.5. Clearly, the size of the residue at position 557 is
not, by itself, a reliable predictor of the product ratio.
3.3. Oxygenation of 11(S)-Deuteriolinoleic acid by the F557V mutant and
wild-type SBLO-1
The formation of 13(S)-HPOD by wild-type SBLO-1 is initiated by
removal of hydrogen from the pro-S position [22,48] on C-11 of linoleic
acid (Scheme 2A). If formation of 9(S)-HPOD by the F557V mutant
occurs by binding in the opposite orientation, this process would be
expected to involve removal of hydrogen from the pro-R position
(Scheme 2B). To test this prediction, we have investigated the action of
F557V on 11(S)-deuteriolinoleic acid (11(S)-DLA). This material was
prepared by a method used previously by Rickert and Klinman [26] and
by Hamberg [40]. Racemic 11-deuteriolinoleic acid was chemically
synthesized and kinetically resolved by incubation with a low con-
centration (3 nM) of wild-type SBLO-1. Because of the specificity of
SBLO-1 for the pro-S position of C-11 and the very large kinetic isotope
effect, the enzyme preferentially oxygenates the 11(R) enantiomer.
After about 50% conversion, the rate of product formation (as judged
by A234) decreased markedly. After 60% conversion, the reaction was
quenched by acidification, and the unreacted 11-deuteriolinoleic acid
was extracted and purified by HPLC. This material should be highly
enriched with the 11(S) enantiomer.
3.2. Oxygenation of linoleic acid by the F557V,R707L double mutant
According to the proposal of Hornung et al. [29], the formation of
9(S)-HPOD from linoleic acid by the F557V mutant involves interaction
of the carboxylate group of the substrate with arg-707 in SBLO-1. To
test this hypothesis, we decided to investigate the F557V,R707L double
mutant. A possible complication with this experiment is that arg-707 is
a conserved residue that forms a hydrogen bond with asp-490 in the
interior of the protein, and loss of this interaction might impede folding
and/or alter the three-dimensional structure. Hornung et al. prepared
the corresponding double mutant (H608V,R758L) of the cucumber
enzyme and found that it had only 5% of the wild-type activity and
converted linoleic acid to a 60:40 mixture of 13-HPOD and 9-HPOD,
both of which were racemic mixtures. We interpret these results as
evidence that the pentadienyl radical intermediate dissociated from the
enzyme and reacted with O2 in solution.
When the F557V,R707L double mutant of SBLO-1 was expressed
according to our standard protocol, the lipoxygenase activity in crude
cell lysates was only about 6% of what is customarily obtained with
wild type. A sample of crude lysate was incubated with 50 mM linoleic
acid at pH 7.5, and the products were reduced with TCEP and analyzed
by HPLC. The ratio of 13-HOD to 9-HOD was 89:11.
Solutions of 11(S)-deuteriolinoleic acid (50 μM) in 100 mM tris
buffer, pH 7.5, were incubated at room temperature with 60 nM of the
F557V mutant, and the products were reduced by TCEP and analyzed
by HPLC, as in the experiments in Table 1. The results of three ex-
periments gave an average of 93.8
0.3% of 9-HOD, compared with
only 37% with unlabeled linoleic acid. The shift in the product ratio is
consistent with the hypothesis that oxygenation at C-9 requires removal
of hydrogen from the pro-R position of C-11 of linoleic acid. The for-
mation of 13(S)-HPOD is known [48] to involve loss of the pro-S hy-
drogen from C-11, and the rate of this process with 11(S)-DLA is ex-
pected to be greatly reduced by the large KIE. If 9-oxygenation requires
loss of hydrogen from the pro-R position, its rate should be reduced
only slightly with 11(S)-DLA, owing to the small secondary isotope
effect [26], so that the ratio of 9-oxygenation to 13-oxygenation should
increase, as is observed.
The 9-HOD and 13-HOD produced by oxygenation of 11(S)-DLA
followed by reduction were purified by HPLC and analyzed by negative-
5