Communications
doi.org/10.1002/ejic.202000919
In this discussion we have focussed primarily on the relative
enthalpies of the reaction mechanism. Naturally, the reaction
rates and equilibria will depend on the corresponding Gibbs
Table 1. Hydroboration of benzophenone with HBpin catalysed by
selected aluminium catalysts.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Catalyst (5 mol% [Al])[a]
Yield [%]
Time [h]
~
free enthalpies ( G), which have been computed by applying
iBu2Al(TMP), 1
iBu2Al(HMDS), 2
[iBu2Al{OC(Me)2C(Me)2O}B(H)(TMP)]2, 3
[iBu2Al{OC(Me)2C(Me)2O}B(H)(HMDS)]2, 4
94
97
35
24
0.5
3
17
21
the harmonic oscillator/rigid rotor approximation and are
~
G
provided in Figure 2 (values in parentheses). However, the
values should be viewed with some caution as the harmonic
oscillator/rigid rotor approximation is known to be problematic
in the case of weakly bound complexes, such as RC, due to the
large number of low-energy vibrational modes, which in turn
have a large contribution to the entropy. Nonetheless, it is
interesting to note the qualitative effect of the entropy on the
enthalpy profile. The inclusion of entropy disfavours the
formation of RC, with a decrease in the number of degrees of
freedom in the system, although the complex formation is only
[a] Conditions: 5 mol% [Al] catalyst loading, C6D6 solvent, room tempera-
ture. All yields estimated against 1H NMR internal standard hexameth-
ylcyclotrisiloxane.
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
yield of Ph2CHOBpin, after 17 hours, in contrast to the near
quantitative conversion obtained within 0.5 hours using 1. As
expected from its similarity to 3, HMDS-borane 4 also performs
poorly as a pre-catalyst, with only 24% conversion after
21 hours at room temperature using 5 mol%. This implies that
both 3 and 4 could exist as off-cycle products from hydro-
boration with 1 and 2 as pre-catalysts, respectively. Therefore, 3
and 4 can be considered deactivation products from these
monometallic aluminium pre-catalysts. Though both possess a
B–H bond, they are occupied within bulky neutral environ-
ments, that greatly diminishes their reducing capability com-
pared to those of charged ate analogues such as the
trialkoxyborohydride formed via addition of nucleophilic NaOt-
Bu to HBpin.[14] However, note that when 1 is used as a pre-
catalyst in hydroborations no signals corresponding to 3 are
seen in 11B NMR spectra. This indicates that in the presence of
benzophenone the rate of hydroboration is greater than the
rate of B–O cleavage and formation of 3.
It is notable that such well-defined examples of elucidated
decomposition products of HBpin of relevance to catalysis are
very rare. B2pin3 is a known, crystallographically-characterised
decomposition product of HBpin.[15] The structure of B2pin3 has
a central O(Me2)CÀ C(Me2)O unit from ring-opening of a HBpin
molecule, but otherwise bears little resemblance to 3 or 4. Hill
reported observing trace amounts of B2pin3 in hydroboration of
imines, catalysed by DIPPNacNacMg(nBu), under forcing
conditions.[16] Other documented examples in main group
systems are known,[17–21] but for most examples of cleavage of
one or both B–O bonds in HBpin or HBcat one has to turn to
transition metal, lanthanide, or actinide complexes.[22–30] Ligand
redistribution reactions between alanes AlX3 and boranes BY3 to
AlX3-nYn and BY3-nXn are also well documented.[31,32] This
redistribution reactivity has been harnessed to generate the
active catalyst Et2AlH from a Et3Al pre-catalyst and HBpin in the
hydroboration of acetylenes.[4c] Similarly, iBu2AlH and HBpin also
undergo ligand scrambling generating iBuBpin and iBu3B,
amongst other products.
~
mildly endergonic on the free enthalpy surface ( G=0.8 kcal/
mol, Figure 2). The subsequent formation of Int1, TS, and Prod,
are relatively unaffected by the inclusion of entropy. Finally, the
formation of 3, while less favourable when entropy is consid-
~
ered, remains a strongly exergonic process ( G=À 24.4 kcal/
mol, Figure 2).
Crystalline 3 exists as a centrosymmetric dimer featuring a
planar kite-shaped AlÀ OÀ AlÀ O core. The Al centre exists in a
distorted tetrahedral geometry comprising two O and two C
°
atoms with bond angles spanning 110.96(7)–117.22(7) , whilst
the B centre is distorted trigonal planar with bond angles in the
°
range 117(2)–122.7(2) . TMP and Al components sit at opposite
1
ends of the ring-opened B-pinacol unit. The H NMR spectrum
of 3 displays the hydride resonance as a broad singlet at
4.75 ppm in C6D6 solution, which sharpens upon applying 11B
decoupling. In comparison, the HBpin hydride resonance is a
broad quartet at 4.17 ppm with a J coupling constant of
171.56 Hz, in C6D6. The 11B NMR spectrum of 3 displays a broad
singlet resonance at 30.0 ppm, while for HBpin this signal
occurs as a doublet at 28.1 ppm (J=174 Hz). The lack of
observed splitting in the 1H and 11B NMR spectra of 3 could be a
result of signal broadening due to a quadrupolar nucleus (11B)
in an asymmetrical environment. A 1H DOSY NMR experiment[13]
on 3 in C6D6 solution gave an estimated molecular weight of
830 g/mol, consistent with retention of the dimer in solution
(818.73 g/mol; À 1% error). The 13C{1H} NMR spectrum displayed
all the expected signals, though no signal was observed in the
27Al spectrum.
A similar outcome is seen reacting together iBu2Al(HMDS) 2
and HBpin in hexane. Crystalline [iBu2Al{OC(Me)2C(Me)2O}B(H)
(HMDS)]2, 4, is formed in a low 24% isolated yield. Its molecular
structure both in the crystal and in C6D6 are analogous to those
of 3 (see SI and Figure S13).
Next, 2, 3, and 4 were applied as pre-catalysts for hydro-
boration of benzophenone with HBpin to check their catalytic
viability (Table 1). The reduction of benzophenone with 5 mol%
of 2 as a pre-catalyst is slower than with 1, requiring 3 hours to
reach 97% conversion, compared to only 0.5 hours to reach
94% conversion with 1 as reported previously.[6] This suggests
that β-hydride transfer in forming the active Al hydride pre-
catalyst is significantly faster with 1 than with 2. Employing
5 mol% of TMP-borane 3 as a pre-catalyst managed only a 35%
In summary, light has been shed on the decomposition of
HBpin when used stoichiometrically with alkylaluminium
amides. When used catalytically these Al amides can hydro-
borate ketones with HBpin at room temperature via a putative
R2AlH intermediate. Such well-defined examples of the break-
down of HBpin with main group metal compounds are rare, but
they are important given the recent escalation of activity in
main group homogeneous catalysis. The products of these
Eur. J. Inorg. Chem. 2021, 50–53
52
© 2020 The Authors. European Journal of Inorganic Chemistry published
by Wiley-VCH GmbH